Hi everyone, I'm new here, but not too new. I have been reading mixmnojo since the early 2000s and I was a member of the forum. I don't remember which account. I apologize in advance for my poor English.
I finished the game yesterday. I was shocked and shocked and stayed that way for a while.
I immediately talked with friends and the amazing thing is that the more you talk about it, the more you like the ending.
I liked the ending immediately, but I METABOLISED it after hours, after slept and after having talked with other "theorists".
Last night this forum was a safe place, there were few replies but I really liked those few.
I found the ending to be very introspective.
I summarize here what I have said and commented elsewhere:
The secret is what you want it to be, almost like a "your future is whatever you make it, so make it a good one".
Guybrush is a storyteller. He may have lived through those stories or not. It doens't matter. They are stories handed down and conversely told again. Each of us experiences a little bit of his mental traps, from time to time. But when the story passes from mouth to mouth it undergoes changes and it is right to vibrate the imagination.
Guybrush is the flooring inspector of an amusement park where he has been working for years. Perhaps the lookout is even the person who is in charge of guarding the gates. After all, the flooring inspector joke happens in the earliest stages of mi1 play.
What we pursue in life can obsess us to the point that when we reach it it can disappoint us. Fantasy allows us to recreate the worlds we want and Boybrush isn't ready for that yet. My theory is that Guybrush is still a dreamer who lives a fulfilling, but not necessarily exciting, reality.
My theory is that Guybrush wanted to give a life lesson to his son, and then realized that it is not the time yet. Much better to get back to playing.
In short, as I wrote almost everywhere:
We are all Guybrush in our 30s, 40s, 50s and so on.
We were all BoyBrush when we played the first Monkey Island in our very early years.
So, I wanted to have my say, Thank you all for the interesting ideas, useful for shaping my personal theory.