..DarthRevan.. Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 Who do you think would win in a fight? Alright my friend and I keep saying who would win in a fight Anakin or Luke. I am thinking that Anakin would win by a long shot but my friend thinks that Luke would win. And remember Anakin not Vader!!!!. So we want to know what you think. Thanks
0DarthRevan0 Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 Okay well im his friend and you have to also remember that the original trilogies were made over twenty years ago and they couldnt have all of the really fast lightsaber fights and jumping around like we saw in the new trilogy. Luke brings the jedi back and could easily beat anakin!!
..DarthRevan.. Posted August 10, 2006 Author Posted August 10, 2006 lol That dosnt matter anakin had better training as a jedi and had the dark side anger with him to attack faster and better. He would kick Luke's A**
0DarthRevan0 Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 And luke didnt use anger when Vader said he was gonna turn Leia if luke didnt turn.
..DarthRevan.. Posted August 10, 2006 Author Posted August 10, 2006 But Anakin turned fully too the dark side. Let's jsut let the people decide. P.S. Do you see what we have to put up with you dicide.
St. Jimmy Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 This should be a poll. Um, Anikan's cooler I'll go with him
YertyL Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 lol That dosnt matter anakin had better training as a jedi and had the dark side anger with him to attack faster and better. He would kick Luke's A** How about: "anakin ... had the dark side anger with him to be beaten by Obi-Wan"? Seriously, IMO it would be like the Anakin - Obi-Wan duel (well, Luke would possibly be slightly more "powerful" than Obi-Wan) and very close - the aggression and raw power of the DS vs. the calmness of the LS. This of course is under the condition that both have the about same level of training. Btw. IMHO Vader > Anakin. I know the GL quotes but I prefer the explanation that Anakin/Vader did not wish to unleash his full power against his son.
Pho3nix Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 Anakin would defeat him, he has had longer training and I think he is more powerfull, even before he became Vader.
grrrrrrrrrr7 Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 Who do you think would win in a fight? Alright my friend and I keep saying who would win in a fight Anakin or Luke. I am thinking that Anakin would win by a long shot but my friend thinks that Luke would win. And remember Anakin not Vader!!!!. So we want to know what you think. Thanks are you talking just about anakin and luke? 'cause if you are, i bet luke would win. now theres always when your talking about, do you mean when they both didnt know what jedi were(anakin as a slave and luke as a farmboy)or when they were both padawans and learning. then again you could mean when they were both masters and expeirenced
Prime Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 Depends on what age Luke is at this point. If they are the same age (early 20's-ish), then Anakin would win as he had years of training at that point and had become a prominant member of the Order. Luke only had very minimal training by that point. If it is an older Luke, then I think he would win, as he had more years of experience to increase his skills.
Shane_1990 Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 Personaley myself anakin, cuz i think he was more the stronger jedi than luke, and when he turns anger fear hate gives anakin more power. And u could even see that obi one was struggoling against anakin whent he turned to the DARK SIDE!.
..DarthRevan.. Posted August 10, 2006 Author Posted August 10, 2006 Exacly what i said Anakin would win. Plus he is the chossen one stronger than the other jedi's too!!! But my friend dosent think so
MachineCult Posted August 10, 2006 Posted August 10, 2006 If you are talking about Luke and Anakin at the same age, like 23 then it's obvious who would win, at that age Anakin was defeating Sith Lords and destroying temples full of Jedi, whereas Luke was getting limbs severed in playfights with his dad.
0DarthRevan0 Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Yeah whatever Luke is stronger and better....
Great Scott! Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 I'm a big Luke fan, but I'd have to say Anakin. He beat Luke in ESB (and would've in RotJ if Vader hadn't turned cool), he was much faster and better trained (although that was only because of how common Jedis were), and he was the chosen one.
MachineCult Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Yeah whatever Luke is stronger and better.... Wow, what a compelling argument, I have completely changed my mind. [/sarcasm] Like Nintendork said, "he was much faster and better trained (although that was only because of how common Jedis were), and he was the chosen one." Anakin FTW.
Jeff Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 Depends on what age Luke is at this point. If they are the same age (early 20's-ish), then Anakin would win as he had years of training at that point and had become a prominant member of the Order. Luke only had very minimal training by that point. If it is an older Luke, then I think he would win, as he had more years of experience to increase his skills. I agree with this statement. Anakin would smoke the Luke in ESB/RotJ, but if it's Luke after he opened the academy, etc, I think he could stand a chance.
..DarthRevan.. Posted August 12, 2006 Author Posted August 12, 2006 Ha i told you jordan Anakin would kick Luke's A** lol thanks everyone!!! But still leave more anwsers everyone if you want.
Darth Smaug Posted August 12, 2006 Posted August 12, 2006 I think that Anakin would win against the Luke with the Blue saber but would lose against the Luke with the Green saber..
PoiuyWired Posted August 12, 2006 Posted August 12, 2006 Now, the thing being green saber Luke might win against Vader in an all out fight, BUT he would probably have to tap heavily on the dark side to do so. Which means, sith pwnd. It is lucky that Vader is still a bit softie and did not use his full power.
TKA-001 Posted August 12, 2006 Posted August 12, 2006 Anakin would smoke Luke any time, unless it's the Luke from NJO with "emerald lightning" and all those other dip**** powers.
0DarthRevan0 Posted August 15, 2006 Posted August 15, 2006 You are all ****ed in the head it doesnt matter that anakin had more training and was the chosen one obi wan kicked his ass and luke did in ROPJ and it doesnt matter that anakin was older and had robot arms or whatever the only reason that he was slower was because of technology and that is why there was so much jumping around in the new trilogy luke was better in the originals and would have been in the new ones to and that is that.
Great Scott! Posted August 15, 2006 Posted August 15, 2006 Whoa... sorry... I didn't know my opinion made me ****ed in the head... EDIT: Wow, the way you edited your post is a lot nicer than "You are all ****ed up in the head and can suck my dick..." But Luke did not kick his ass in RotJ, Vader saved Luke at the expense of his own life...
Jeff Posted August 15, 2006 Posted August 15, 2006 Well look at it this way. In the prequals all the Jedi trained for years in lightsaber combat and that's why the duels in the PT were a much faster pace than in the OT. The RotJ duel was supposed to be like an untrained rookie against a crippled aging sith. There's no way Luke could defeat any jedi knight or master from the prequel days.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.