Jump to content

Home

Something is wrong in this text... (WW2)


Air Juggernaut

Recommended Posts

Today, reading the Osprey/Military book T-34/85 Medium Tank I found this on the "T-34/85 against King Tiger" section: a tank commander called Oskin do a comment about when his thank meet an encounter against King Tigers in Poland (his tank was hidden in a crop field). The text indicate that Oskin open fire against a King Tiger at 200 meters and in the turret side, but although the shot enter and kill part of the crew the tank was not destroyed, so he order to the loader to put a special ammo and order the gunner to shot at the rear tank fuel (1), after it other King Tiger move it turret in order to find the enemy and the Oskin´s tank put three shots in the front of turret (2) without damaging it.

Conclusions:

1) King Tigers don´t has rear fuel tanks and Oskin remember that it was like a Panther but more big, the only german tank with rear fuel tanks is the MAUS

2) The front of the turret of the King Tiger is very narrow to allow a gunner put three shots here, but the MAUS has a very big front turret.

So, the MAUS tank enter in combat or that text is wrong.

 

------------------

"All your base are belong to us", "Surrender for your own good"

- Kanon Siege Forces, 2001

Kanon´s Robotic Facility

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Two things are possible:

1) heavy storytelling on the part of the Russian tanker. Making up glorious stories or forgetting details for the sake of the story are common in war

2) the King Tiger was heavily modified in the field, which I assume could have been very possible. I've read of tank crews tying down pieces of iron plate (from other destroyed tanks or even the door off of a wood burning stove) to the turrets and so forth in order to gain a bit of extra armor. If they had armored the turret in such a manner, it's possible the gunner did hit the King Tiger three times and have it survive. The rear fuel tank may have been a similar modification. Or it simply may not have been a fuel tank at all. It could have just been some kind of tank-like object the Panzer was carrying for some reason (just like Russian tanks carrying captured bathtubs for some reason).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Nute Gunray:

Or it simply may not have been a fuel tank at all. It could have just been some kind of tank-like object the Panzer was carrying for some reason (just like Russian tanks carrying captured bathtubs for some reason).

 

From Usenet:

 

. . . You just blew up the enemy's portable cooler full of beer, the driver's fishing supplies, a change of clothes, and the gunner's stash of porn. They're probably not gonna be too happy with you right now. . .

 

------------------

"Don't f_ck with the Jedi Master, son." --Mark Hamill

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"Don't screw with a tanker's beer."

 

------------------

"Here, people don't lock their doors, they deadbolt them, and then stick a chair under the knob."

ThRaWn90,RAL_Thrawn,SOB_Thrawn

Rogue 6

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well thanks to this story Oskin is was like a national hero. Well, one of the king tigers of that story is on kubinka museum or other russian armor museum, checking it should show all that modifications.

 

------------------

"All your base are belong to us", "Surrender for your own good"

- Kanon Siege Forces, 2001

Kanon´s Robotic Facility

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Air Juggernaut:

I´m looking for them in yahoo for a while but I don´t get nothing good mad.gif

 

 

WARNING: DOUBLE NEGATIVE ALERT!!!

 

CORRECT RESPONSE: I'm looking for them in Yahoo for a while, but I didn't get anything good. mad.gif

 

 

(I always get the best English grades in my class. smile.gif )

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by JR2000Z:

Just so you remember:

 

A negative+negative=positive.

 

Horray, I'm the first one to tell him!

NEGATIVE PLUS NEGATIVE EQUALS NEGATIVE.

 

You're thinking of multiplication or grammar.

 

 

 

 

------------------

You're supposed to be dumpster-diving for ham scraps, you six-piece chicken McNobody!

 

Official forum Psychic

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Taarkin:

Originally posted by JR2000Z:

Just so you remember:

 

A negative+negative=positive.

 

Horray, I'm the first one to tell him!

NEGATIVE PLUS NEGATIVE EQUALS NEGATIVE.

 

You're thinking of multiplication or grammar.

 

 

 

But what I said did make sence.

 

I´m looking for them in yahoo for a while but I don´t get nothing good

 

So if he doesnt get 'nothing good' then he must have gotten something.

 

 

Oh yeah, the don't should have been didn't since don't reffers to a plural noun in this case.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don´t worry, Nute ever finish the job, he only take his time. I remember that he take a time to send me Veritech blueprints time ago. I hope..

 

------------------

"All your base are belong to us", "Surrender for your own good"

- Kanon Siege Forces, 2001

Kanon´s Robotic Facility

 

[This message has been edited by Air Juggernaut (edited September 22, 2001).]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...