Guest Hannibal Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Vader was never trying to kill Luke. He was trying to turn him. If he wanted to kill luke there would never have been a ROTJ. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Hannibal Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Vader was never trying to kill Luke. He was trying to turn him. If he wanted to kill luke there would never have been a ROTJ. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Mojo Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Vader wins. No doubt about it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Mojo Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Vader wins. No doubt about it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest BigBud Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 But he was trying to kill him in ROTJ. Not at first, but then he said "IF you will not join us, you shall die". This has no relevince anyways, Vader is Very slow... Maul flips over Vader, Vader cant turn it time, and OHHHHHHHHHHHH. He has ben choped in half. I dont care what system your from, thats got to hurt. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest BigBud Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 But he was trying to kill him in ROTJ. Not at first, but then he said "IF you will not join us, you shall die". This has no relevince anyways, Vader is Very slow... Maul flips over Vader, Vader cant turn it time, and OHHHHHHHHHHHH. He has ben choped in half. I dont care what system your from, thats got to hurt. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Darth Rave Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Ya Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Darth Rave Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Ya Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Jedi Kenobi Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Another thing is that the movie quality then wasn't as good. Heck, if they had the technolagy (spelled wrong, I know) they had now the original trilogy's jedi battles would be much more fast paced like ep. 1. Also, why would they be fighting in the first place? They are commanded by the same guy! (Sideous-Palpatine) ------------------ Jedi Kenobi Jedi Knight Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Jedi Kenobi Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Another thing is that the movie quality then wasn't as good. Heck, if they had the technolagy (spelled wrong, I know) they had now the original trilogy's jedi battles would be much more fast paced like ep. 1. Also, why would they be fighting in the first place? They are commanded by the same guy! (Sideous-Palpatine) ------------------ Jedi Kenobi Jedi Knight Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Jedi Ami-Naki Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 I think Jedi Kenobi has a point there we are comparing fighting styles from movies form two different eras, TPM did extensive work on the fight scenes and Ray Parks is an martial arts expert for gods sake. They just didn't have that in Ep4-6. I think if they redid them Lucas would pump up those fight scenes. But I think Vader slaughter Maul no contest. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Jedi Ami-Naki Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 I think Jedi Kenobi has a point there we are comparing fighting styles from movies form two different eras, TPM did extensive work on the fight scenes and Ray Parks is an martial arts expert for gods sake. They just didn't have that in Ep4-6. I think if they redid them Lucas would pump up those fight scenes. But I think Vader slaughter Maul no contest. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest liquidkid Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 yo, i dont care if i do piss anyone off at this point... saying that luke is a wussy? dude... you guys are dicks!!! luke is the best!!!! he didnt even start training as a jedi until he was old enough to be going off to starfleet academy. and kenobi is absolutely right. they didnt have the technology back then to make the fights as good. imagine if they redid the fight scenes in esb and rotj? oh my god i would piss my pants... and we're not talkin about "2 drops" ------------------ p.l.u.r. <> J9K-4-LIFE <> MCL JEDI-4-LIFE Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest liquidkid Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 yo, i dont care if i do piss anyone off at this point... saying that luke is a wussy? dude... you guys are dicks!!! luke is the best!!!! he didnt even start training as a jedi until he was old enough to be going off to starfleet academy. and kenobi is absolutely right. they didnt have the technology back then to make the fights as good. imagine if they redid the fight scenes in esb and rotj? oh my god i would piss my pants... and we're not talkin about "2 drops" ------------------ p.l.u.r. <> J9K-4-LIFE <> MCL JEDI-4-LIFE Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Barnabas Antilies Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Your right they are dicks. I would poop in a sock if they redid the scene with Ben fighting vader. ------------------ Father Barnabas Antilies, Supreme Chancelor Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Barnabas Antilies Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Your right they are dicks. I would poop in a sock if they redid the scene with Ben fighting vader. ------------------ Father Barnabas Antilies, Supreme Chancelor Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Jedi Trunks Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Maul would kick butt, he has som many more combos and what not, No chance for vader, way to slow, just like a plo koon! ------------------ Trunks, Supreme Jedi "I was merely here to save a life, now I must kick some Cell Ass." Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Jedi Trunks Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Maul would kick butt, he has som many more combos and what not, No chance for vader, way to slow, just like a plo koon! ------------------ Trunks, Supreme Jedi "I was merely here to save a life, now I must kick some Cell Ass." Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest BigBud Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Ya, that is a good point. I was think about that as I made my last post. Though you have changed my opionon, you have not totally swead me. I dont think maul would kick vaders ass anymore, but instead think it would be a great fight to the death. I have no apinion anymore, because they both have there strengths. All I can say is, GREAT FIGHT. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest BigBud Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Ya, that is a good point. I was think about that as I made my last post. Though you have changed my opionon, you have not totally swead me. I dont think maul would kick vaders ass anymore, but instead think it would be a great fight to the death. I have no apinion anymore, because they both have there strengths. All I can say is, GREAT FIGHT. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest BigBud Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 That last post was for liquidkid. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest BigBud Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 That last post was for liquidkid. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Plo Koon Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Let me add this too. Since ANH was made in the 70's, Lucas couldn't find light enough material to allow David Prowse (Vader's physical movement) to move around in easily. Lucas had to make the battle slow so Prowse didn't rip the material, and that is why he turns his whole body when he turns his head. I think the battle would be awesome if they could find new, light material for David Prowse to move freely in. I still think Vader would rip him a new a-hole if they fought. Maul would piss his pants just looking at Vader. Look how short Maul is too. Vader is about 7'2, and Maul is about 5'5 to 6' even. Oh well, Vader could just think about killing Maul, and Maul would die. I think most of you that want Maul to win are Maul fans. I don't care who would win, so realistically, I choose Vader. Yep. ------------------ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Plo Koon Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Let me add this too. Since ANH was made in the 70's, Lucas couldn't find light enough material to allow David Prowse (Vader's physical movement) to move around in easily. Lucas had to make the battle slow so Prowse didn't rip the material, and that is why he turns his whole body when he turns his head. I think the battle would be awesome if they could find new, light material for David Prowse to move freely in. I still think Vader would rip him a new a-hole if they fought. Maul would piss his pants just looking at Vader. Look how short Maul is too. Vader is about 7'2, and Maul is about 5'5 to 6' even. Oh well, Vader could just think about killing Maul, and Maul would die. I think most of you that want Maul to win are Maul fans. I don't care who would win, so realistically, I choose Vader. Yep. ------------------ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Pizza the Hutt Posted April 27, 2000 Share Posted April 27, 2000 Uh...there's no technology involved in those fighting sequences. It's actors with colored sticks. The fights are what they are, and Vader and Luke couldn't compete with Maul, Kenobi and Jinn. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.