-
Posts
6028 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Darth InSidious's Achievements
Single Status Update
See all updates by Darth InSidious
-
Surely not!
Grr, Darathy. I'm reading a bit of a book by Steven Pinker - "The Language Instinct" - and he just ravaged a bit of W in it.
Philosophers argue that since animals lack language, they must also lack consciousness-- Wittgenstein wrote, "A dog could not have the thought 'perhaps it will rain tomorrow'"--and therefore they do not possess the rights of conscious beings. [p56, The Language Instinct]
I'm not really sure how it's possible to misconstrue W so badly that you end up with the above sentence unless you're just quote-mining. But you'd expect a "leading linguist" to actually, well, read linguistic philosophy...