Joshi Posted December 19, 2001 Posted December 19, 2001 2D + Mouse = great game. Take this into account, nice Lucas Arts people. p.s. please excuse spelling in signature, i was in a rush, but i hope you get the message and please add a 'happy new year' on the end:)
Joshi Posted December 19, 2001 Posted December 19, 2001 yes i repeated myself, but i wanted to get the point across, and hopefully get more votes. later.
monkeydude Posted December 19, 2001 Posted December 19, 2001 y would u want a 2d game.3d is clearly amazing
monkeydude Posted December 19, 2001 Posted December 19, 2001 2d would be good because u can fit more puzzles in instead of takin up loads of memory on the graphics but it would have to be as good as monkey3s graphics or better
mumpizz Posted December 20, 2001 Posted December 20, 2001 I vote for 2D!!! Handdrawn graphics add much more to the atmosphere than 3D-rendered Images do. ...just my opinion...
fat-boy-glottis Posted December 23, 2001 Posted December 23, 2001 Monkey Island 4 was good, but I preferred it when it was 2-D. It worked much better
Meksilon Posted December 26, 2001 Posted December 26, 2001 I vote for NO MI5. And Technically speaking any movement in the 3D world does add the element of time (let's say a character MOVING) making it technically 4D - However you will always have to see it on a 3D monitor (2D screen that refreshes). =mek= PS: EMI sucks.
MancombSeepgood Posted January 17, 2002 Posted January 17, 2002 Who said there's better detail in 3d? better than MI1 and 2, yeah, but definitely not better than MI3. the 3d in MI4 is so wooden, the characters are all polygonal. What's with that stupid grin Guybrush has plastered onto his face all the way through MI4? it's so annoying. the energy/memory put into making an object 3d is all that's done, they never actually put detail into it because they think the fact that it's 3d is enough to satisfy players. well it isn't! the only detail in 3d is shading. and the fact that you can walk around it. the detail sure as HECK (pardon my language) isn't better in the 3d game, that much is obvious.
Guybrush_3pwood Posted January 17, 2002 Posted January 17, 2002 Keep the monkey island fashion going and make it 2D! I agree. I mean if they're going to make a monkey island in 3D, at least make it the best in graphics. I got an idea. Anyone here played Oddworld: Abe's Exoddus ? Well look at the movies in it. They are better than Shrek's graphics. Even though it was a cool movie. But in Oddworld, they make sure that they include every detail. Have a look! If you want to see it click here!
zachfishman Posted January 20, 2002 Posted January 20, 2002 They could work the aspect of two-dimensions into the plot: Pirates all over the Tri-Island area are losing their third dimension, becoming 2 dimensional. Guybrush has to find the cure. While to suit your request of having the whole game in 2D, one or two islands could have progressed enough to be entirely 2D.
Dracyia Posted January 22, 2002 Posted January 22, 2002 2d is bettr, but if they do it in 2d theyll loose the audience theyve gained. shame, but if they put it in 3d theres more chance of more games coming out.
Parang Posted January 23, 2002 Posted January 23, 2002 In my opinion MI5 should be in 2D like CMI as it was much easier to handle. In CMI the backgrounds were lovely (-->the mill on blood island)
mcfly Posted February 22, 2002 Posted February 22, 2002 Why not the best of both worlds - Cartoon Rendering!
Guybrush_3pwood Posted February 27, 2002 Posted February 27, 2002 Of course we want 2D. Bring back 2D and they will get lots of money.
MonkeyBastard Posted February 27, 2002 Posted February 27, 2002 Monkey Island is a great series, but there is NO DOUBT that parts 3 and 4 were nothing compared to parts 1 and 2. 2D LIVES!!!!!! A brand new Monkey Island game in the old 2D style would be a dream come true. To the game developers: You don't have to follow the trends of today. You don't have to make a game 3D. I for one am pretty tired of all the generic looking 3d games. Monkey Island is a game that should be 2D. It was perfect just the way it was. So please, do us hardcore fans a favor and bring back the glory days of 2D gaming. You'll sell a lot more copies... guaranteed. I'll buy 2! And if you don't believe me that 2D is desired, just check out the sales of Gameboy Advance. It's done extremely well. Why? because it allows people to relive some of the greatest 2d games ever. And that's what it's all about. -MonkeyBastard
Joshi Posted March 18, 2002 Posted March 18, 2002 to all those people who came here asking for a 3d mi5, i think you got it wrong, u see, this topic was for people who wanted a 2d monkey island 5, so get off this topic! p.s. 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 2D MONKEY ISLAND 5 THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.!
Parang Posted April 16, 2002 Posted April 16, 2002 As I see it most of those who can vividly remember the release of The Secret of Monkey Island think that 2D rulz. They are melancholic. In my opinion melancholia rockz. BACK TO THE ROOTS!
mumpizz Posted April 18, 2002 Posted April 18, 2002 cool, just discovered this thread btw: real pirates only need 2 dimensions!
YTtheMighty Posted April 23, 2002 Posted April 23, 2002 I think it would be better, and by better I mean more sutible to the series, MI4 was alright but it lacked something, the graphics aren't the main problem, the problem is there is no Ron Gilbert, the end of MI2 could lead so many ways and it just isn't right to have MI3 written by anyone other than Ron, MI3 was great, but it wasn't the same.
Joshi Posted April 24, 2002 Posted April 24, 2002 you know, you can ask and ask, but no matter how many times you ask (and believe me i've tried) i don't think ron will come back. and thata's a real downer considering he had plans for an MI3 which wasn't what it is now, and now we'll never know what they were. sad really.
ZoE GurL Posted April 26, 2002 Posted April 26, 2002 2D all the way! It'll bring back some of the old charm of the first 3 oh... and i do come to wonder how most of the ppl that posted in this thread have only ever posted once or twice, and ONLY ever in this thread... just seems a lil dodge to me
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.