Guest Khameir_Sarin Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 I was just wondering, for i am a fan of both Lord of the Rings and Star Wars, if anyine else here likes BOTH of them. Or do all SW fans hate LOTR and LOTR fans hate SW?! I think Star Wars is great science fiction I think LOTR is great fantasy -And if youve never read LOTR, but still hate it, you SUCK! Thats just as wrong as a LOTR fan who has never watched star wars!
Eets Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 I've never read it, but hearing a description of it and seeing the movie trailer makes me a huge fan of it! I like it..
Guest Khameir_Sarin Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 LOL hahahahaha Thats cool. Your right, the movie looks SWEET!
Eets Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 Yeah, I decided I'd see it even though it had one major shortcoming.. Elijah Wood.
Guest Luke Skywalker Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 All SW fans should like LOTR as I have said before. They are the same story but in different contexts. Im a hugs fan of both.
Eets Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 I dunno, he just gets on my nerves for some reason..
Silenthunter Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 I'v read all the books and I love LotR. Maybe not quite as much as SW, but I think the books were cool and the movie is going to be awesome!
Guest Rogue15 Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 Only reason why i like star wars is because it is Science Fiction. Like the ships and vehicles and weapons, those are more science fiction than fantasy.
mkruzel Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 I remember seeing the LOTR cartoon in the theatre a long time ago pretty close to around when Star Wars came out. I don't remember what year it was though.
Guest DarkTrooper Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 Originally posted by Eets'chula Yeah, I decided I'd see it even though it had one major shortcoming.. Elijah Wood. yeah that kid pisses me of too. wasnt he in a very bad movie about a meteor tryin to hit earth. that movie sucked. it was a cheap take-off of Armageddon
Eets Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 deep impact, yeah. But they were both released at the same time, so neither are really spoofs of the other..
Guest Luke Skywalker Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 DOes anyone Read Harry Potter? I sure don't.
Guest crazy_dog Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 Harry Potter. It's OK, but isn't the greatest... I actaully like HP.
Guest Luke Skywalker Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 Ive heard some bad jokes about him too. There are tons of Anti-you know who sites, they all have hilarious jokes. Ill post a few appropriate ones.
Guest Khameir_Sarin Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 I think all HP fans will be blown away by the money the LOTR movie makes over the money made by the HP movie.
Guest Lord Tirion Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 LOTR and HP are not even in the same boat nor should they even be compared. LOTR is serious Dark Fantasy where as HP is mostly for kids and is light sided. I don't think you are gonna see people getting limbs lopped off in an HP movie.
darthfergie Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 I LOVE THEM BOTH!!! They ROCK!!! But LOTR doesn't have a HUGE amount of books to read so I'm not into it as much as SW... BTW, Harry Potter is pretty good reading...as for the movie...where in the WORLD did they get those actors!!! A friend of mine looks EXACTLY like Harry Potter from the covers of the books and he won't need any makeup to play the part!!!
Darth_Rommel Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 I read the books, and enjoyed them. I plan to see LOTR, and if it's anywhere near as good as the books... well SW may have some competition
Guest ICP Ringmaster Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 LOTR is an awsome fantasy collestion..it has its own laugages ,species, time era, and everything. im curently reading The return of the king
Silenthunter Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 im curently reading The return of the king That (in my opinion) is the best one! A little while ago i wanted to reread the trilogy, but not take the time read all three books, so i just read that one. It really is amazing how much more you notice the second time through:)
Guest Luke Skywalker Posted October 27, 2001 Posted October 27, 2001 Im rereading the books for the fourth time, it is absolutely amazing how much you miss the first, second, and third times.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.