Jump to content

Home

Who ordered the clone in AOTC


Darth Exar Kun

Who ordered the clone army  

50 members have voted

  1. 1. Who ordered the clone army

    • Jedi Master Sifo Dyas
      8
    • Jedi Master Qui-Gon Jinn
      4
    • Darth Sidous
      12
    • Count Dooku
      15
    • Chanceller Papelitine
      10
    • Someone else
      1


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 62
  • Created
  • Last Reply

The cloners got the order from one who called himself Sifa Dyas, but Obi-Wan had a feeling that the order came after Sifas death.

I guess that some dark guy ordered them for evil work.

 

Have u noticed how much clonetroopers look like stormtroopers?Only the mask is different.

 

 

http://al.jediknightii.net/dcm/strips/104.gif

 

 

http://al.jediknightii.net/dcm/strips/86.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Obi-Doo

Have u noticed how much clonetroopers look like stormtroopers?Only the mask is different.

 

 

http://al.jediknightii.net/dcm/strips/104.gif

 

 

http://al.jediknightii.net/dcm/strips/86.gif

 

That is because after Palpatine takes control of the army, they gradually change into the storrmtroopers under the command of the emperor (palpatine).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok 1st off Obi-Wan pronounced his name "Seifer Diaz" the dialect that the Kaminoans used it sounds like Sifo Diaz. But he's Count Dooku. Just to say some little nOOb said that Darth Maul was Seifer Diaz this is not true, and contrary to what some may think they heard is true Darth Maul doesn't come back in Ep3 he was cut in half at the end of Ep1. Anyways back on topic it was Count Dooku who placed the order when he was a Jedi.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, for one thing, IMO, Darth Sidious and Chancellor Palpatine should be one choice (it's pretty obvious they're the same person.)

 

Second, Qui-Gon Jinn? Uh, no.

 

It's either Darth Tyranus (Dooku) under the orders of Sidious, or Sidious himself. I believe that the word "Sifo-Dyas" when said by the Kaminoan, was mispronounced for "Sidious." Maybe that word just doesn't work on the Kaminoan tongue. In the original script, the name was "Sido-Dyas," even closer to "Sidious." I think Obi-Wan siumply mistook the name for a Jedi who coincidentally has the same name.

 

It makes sense if it was Sidious because as Supreme Chancellor, you can't have an Empire without an army. It would take forever, or not get enough votes, to create an army from drafts or volunteers, so why not create obedient clones that will take Palpatine's every order?

 

Having a hard time deciding between "Darth Sidious" and "Chancellor Palpatine." I'll take Sidious because the name sounds better, I suppose.

 

And finally, Master "Sifo-Dyas" probably has absolutely no connection with the clones at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Shadow Angel

It's either Darth Tyranus (Dooku) under the orders of Sidious, or Sidious himself. I believe that the word "Sifo-Dyas" when said by the Kaminoan, was mispronounced for "Sidious." Maybe that word just doesn't work on the Kaminoan tongue. In the original script, the name was "Sido-Dyas," even closer to "Sidious." I think Obi-Wan siumply mistook the name for a Jedi who coincidentally has the same name.

B]

 

Oooh... that's a possibility! Cool, Shadow Angel! :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I believe it was Qui-Gon because of the way Dooku said not a exact quote iwhich i dont remember but it was something like i knew qui-gon better than you.

And everyone remember Dooku had no idea about the clones and Qui-Gon died ten years ago why not Qui-Gon he did always dissobay the concil sifo dias is nothing like sidous and sidious and papeltine are same person i didnt think of it before if ther senate was controlled by sidous and papeltine controlled the senate ssame person

:sithm::dsaber::lightning

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Didn't someone say Siafa Diaz(or whatever?) was the same name of a jedi that died long ago? Why couldn't SD be Sidious, but SD just faked his death when he fell to the dark side so the jedi wouldn't bother him.

 

 

He could then train his aprentices, place large orders of clones, and become a leading senator in peace.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Darth Exar Kun

Dooku had no idea about the clones

 

*cough*BS*cough*

 

Dooku did know about the clones.

(all following quotes, made by Dooku)

"Good news, master. The war has begun."

 

Dooku stood beside Jango, the guy they used to clone, at the arena.

 

"There are no Bounty hunters here, the Geonosians don't trust them."

 

"How could the jedi come up with an army so quickly? Oh, now I remember! I went to Kamino under the name of Sifo-Dias just so I could pretend to be a jedi so I can get my master, Chancellor palpatine some clones! Of ocurse, I am not going to act like I knew about the clones, cause then you would know that I am just pretending to care for our cause so we can start a war and my master can come to supreme power."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by obi-wan13

 

*cough*BS*cough*

 

Dooku did know about the clones.

(all following quotes, made by Dooku)

"Good news, master. The war has begun."

 

Dooku stood beside Jango, the guy they used to clone, at the arena.

 

"There are no Bounty hunters here, the Geonosians don't trust them."

 

"How could the jedi come up with an army so quickly? Oh, now I remember! I went to Kamino under the name of Sifo-Dias just so I could pretend to be a jedi so I can get my master, Chancellor palpatine some clones! Of ocurse, I am not going to act like I knew about the clones, cause then you would know that I am just pretending to care for our cause so we can start a war and my master can come to supreme power."

 

 

 

 

The boy is right so this saying comes to mind HAHA.

I told ya so in my post.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by SeraphimII

Also why are they two slots for Chanceller Papelitine and Lord Sidiuos?

 

Good question. I don't see why people can't get the fact that Palpatine IS Sidious.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sifo was on the concil and jedis knew of him if Dooku was on the concul how could they be the same person and i posted paplitine and sidous separate to use all of the opotions the clones weren't ordered by dooku why would he let them fight against himself smart fella create a massaive army and let it destroy your other army dooku is nt dias and dooku became darth tyrains like anakin to darth vader

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not defending the dooku theory or anything but he fought aganted the clones with his droid army so he could test the clones, show the entire republic how strong their new army was (Kill the sepritists movement), and the clone army (might have) distroyed the Trade federation and anyone who knew of Sidious besides Dooku.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Darth Exar Kun

Sifo was on the concil and jedis knew of him if Dooku was on the concul how could they be the same person and i posted paplitine and sidous separate to use all of the opotions the clones weren't ordered by dooku why would he let them fight against himself smart fella create a massaive army and let it destroy your other army dooku is nt dias and dooku became darth tyrains like anakin to darth vader

 

I say again:

 

Dooku is not Sifo Dias. He did, however, go to Kamino under that name, to earn their trust. And the clone army was Chancellor Palpatine/Darth Sidious's idea. And seeing how Dooku is Sidious's apprentice of evil and all, Dooku hired Jango to make clones of himself.

 

:jango: "I was hired by a man called Tyrannus."

 

edit- USE PERIODS AND COMMAS AND WHATNOT!

 

Reading your post almost gave me a headache......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I still say that Qui-Gon Jinn order them. Sifo Diyas is not in the star wars databank? Which got me thinking ( a very rare event ) Did he exist at all maybe that was a sith or Qui-Gons allias to infulltrate the concill once at is done he could fake his death. or it was Qui-Gons revenge against the concill for never letting him join (yes it sounded as cheesy writing it as it is reading it)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...