Sivy Posted August 12, 2002 Share Posted August 12, 2002 As I have already posted. It IS supposed to be Qui-Gonn's voice. However Liam Neeson did not record it, they took his voice from Ep I. Both GL and Liam Neeson have confirmed this. They probably took the 'Anakin' part from 'Anakin drop!' The 'No!' I not sure about because I don't remember Qui-Gonn shouting 'no!' in EP I so it may be someone else's voice. But the whole thing IS supposed to be Qui-Gonn. If they had used Luke's voice for the 'no!' it doesn't matter, there is no meaning to it. It's just because they didn't have Liam shouting 'no!' on tape. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
razorace Posted August 12, 2002 Share Posted August 12, 2002 It IS supposed to be Qui-Gonn's voice. However Liam Neeson did not record it, they took his voice from Ep I. Both GL and Liam Neeson have confirmed this. Is there a source that says Neeson didn't record it? I keep hearing people say this but I've heard no source for it yet.... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Breton Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 Hmm this is a crazy idea, but I will post it anyway Lets say that when Jinn died, he was living further as a kind of ghost, and watched Anakin get trained. And when Anakin got mad and killed tuskens, Qui-Gon was screaming " Anakin! Anakin! Noooooooo!".... and then he was almost totally dead. But then Qui-Gon born himself anew as Luke Skywalker, and therefore got the chance to get Anakin over to the Light Side again. But the new Qui-Gon, or Luke, had no memory of this, of course. Evidense 1: If you imagine a young Jinn, he might not have looked so much different than Luke. So this may mean that Luke was totally the same as Qui-Gon Evidense 2: Many of you indicate that it was Lukes voice that screamed noooo, this supports the other evidence I do not say I belive this is true, far from it, it was just a cool theory. = ? Would be funny if it was... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sivy Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 Because like obi-wan, he couldn't rest until he had corrected his mistake. Interesting Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
razorace Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 That's too farfetched for me. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MaulerZ Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 Originally posted by razorace That's too farfetched for me. Hehe same here some peoples comments just leave me confused and saying WTF????? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
razorace Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 no arguement here. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JandoFett1842 Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 where did you get that idea, Qui-Gon all the way Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MaulerZ Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 Originally posted by JandoFett1842 where did you get that idea, Qui-Gon all the way I think he got it from Ep2 Anakin Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
"thA dekMan" Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 why would it be luke, there is almost no reason for it. He isn't even born. It makes much more sense if it was qui-gon, beacause hes dead, so he can prolly send thoughts (althought he didn't disapear so....) and hes the one that believed anakin was "the one" edit: just read ur theory... its a good one, but pretty damn far fetched if i say so my self. Could happen though. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Weapon X Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 craziest goddamned idea ever: we hear qui-gon, from when anakin was younger then we hear lukes scream then we hear vader's breathing maybe yoda is hearing what eventually happens to anakin, kinda like his evolution, we hear when he was younger, when he tells luke he's his father then the final breathing of vader? who knows, no flames just my thoughts and to reply to padawan, vader's breathing was something totally separate right? right, then why can't the "NOOOOOOO!" be someone separate too? you have no logical explanation why one thing can be separate but not another thing, i don't understand why all this arguing has to happen, why doesn't someone with the movie downloaded (pirated copying bastards!!!!) just take that clip and post it on here, find out how to cut a segment out and post it Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Darth Groovy Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 Originally posted by Darth Groovy You do mean "Qui Gon" right? Did you even see the phantom menace movie? At any rate it really is supposed to be Qui-Gonn's voice. You can't go by what you thougth you heard. In The Empire Strikes Back Special Edition, when luke finally falls off of the weather vane his scream sounds exactly like the emporer in Return of the Jedi when Vader throws him down the shaft in the Death Star. And note this, in Raiders of the lost ark, during the truck chase sequence when Indy accidentally hits a bunch of workers on ladders one of them screams exactly like a stormtrooper when he falls, off the catwalk in the Death Star in A New Hope. Take it from someone who has seen these movies entirely too many times. (edit) When I first posted this reply I was a little drunk. This is what I meant to say....sorry:( BTW I think some of you guys are reading into this way too much and making stuff up. This is about as silly as the idea that Palpatine and Darth Sideous are different people........get real! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
razorace Posted August 13, 2002 Share Posted August 13, 2002 Originally posted by ep2 Anakin craziest goddamned idea ever: we hear qui-gon, from when anakin was younger then we hear lukes scream ...... That's much less crazy than the Qui-Gon reborn as Luke theory. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.