XERXES Posted January 10, 2003 Posted January 10, 2003 Originally posted by Hyperglide Dude you are missing the point. The point is what is the better CGI animated character. Obviously, Gandalf the grey AND the white isn't a CGI char (hence Ian Mckellan), so how can you compare the two?? lol.. they are both the wise person that everybody looks up to in the movies.
Hyperglide Posted January 10, 2003 Posted January 10, 2003 Originally posted by XERXES they are both the wise person that everybody looks up to in the movies. Yes mentor wise, they are equals. What I meant was, that it is impossible to compare them physically. At least Gollum and Yoda are similar in terms of their CGI graphics (and in Yodas case enhancement, over his puppet form, I personally liked the puppet more), which this poll and thread is based on.
Lord Glorfindel Posted January 11, 2003 Posted January 11, 2003 Originally posted by Agen_Terminator If gollum wins this....... Will gollum be the new Yoda! Possibilities.. this opens up..... Gollum doesn't have clear thought like Yoda, and has only a few catchy lines, as in Yoda every word is worth rememberance Judge me by my size do u?
DiRtY $oUtH™ Posted January 11, 2003 Posted January 11, 2003 Hmm...let's play a game...it's called Yoda is better.
Andy867 Posted January 11, 2003 Posted January 11, 2003 How bout we play a game called.... Let evil win, and Gollum beats out Yoda But I'd prefer a title more like Gollum's Cave as opposed to Gollum's Fish Pond. Its more fitting, (and more accurate).
JediNyt Posted January 11, 2003 Author Posted January 11, 2003 My thinking is that the Cantina will take the place of the Swamp eventually. And a Gollum theme would not work here hence this is Lucas Forums not Tolkien Forums.
DiRtY $oUtH™ Posted January 11, 2003 Posted January 11, 2003 Originally posted by JediNyt My thinking is that the Cantina will take the place of the Swamp eventually. And a Gollum theme would not work here hence this is Lucas Forums not Tolkien Forums. LMFAO..."Tolkien Forums"....he has a point there.
Darklighter Posted January 11, 2003 Posted January 11, 2003 I couldn't possibly decide. Yoda is the original and best Jedi Master, but then again Golumn is a pretty devious and cunning bad guy. Equal, IMO.
Klorel Posted January 11, 2003 Posted January 11, 2003 I am a fan of yoda, but this one has to go to Smeeeeeagol. If you payed close attention during the movie, Gollum interacts with his "real" environment in ways yoda only dreamt about. Just watch as the CG gollum tugs on Frodos shirt in front of the black gate, you almost can't tell he's CG. Also his skin has more of a slimy yet skin like texture while yoda has good skin too, it doesn't quite match gollums quality. Also the fabric flows and swings much more realistically than yodas, not to say Lucas did a bad job on yoda, he is superb, but when comparing him to gollum... Gollum is just too precioussssss. -Klorel
Wolfey Posted January 11, 2003 Posted January 11, 2003 I think Yoda's great, but gollum is better. I mean, look at Yoda's mouth when hes talkin, it looks plain fake.
Reborn Outcast Posted January 11, 2003 Posted January 11, 2003 Gollum because his movement look so real. Like when the rope is tied around his neck in TTT and he is thrashing about... it looks so real Yoda on the other hand... the only time he every did anything involving movement was the lightsaber battle when it looked VERY fake.
Altus_Thrawn Posted January 14, 2003 Posted January 14, 2003 they're both really good...I can't really say. so equal.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.