Dragonlancer Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 This is kinda dumb, but I noticed something kind of interesting. In aotc, the scene with yoda and the young jedi students, obi-wan comes in and asks for help in locating kamino. in response, yoda says (after some dialogue) "find master obi-wans wayward planet, we will try " I find it interesting in that in aotc he says "try" but in a scene we are all to familiar with (on dagobah, (spelling)) yoda tells luke "No! Do! Or do not. There is no try." Just something I noticed. any thoughts? could maybe even the 800+ year old jedi master end up learning a little lesson of his own? Or did George simply not think of that while writing the script.
Sivy Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 Originally posted by Dragonlancer Or did George simply not think of that while writing the script. yeah or maybe it was something that he'd learnt after that. or maybe it just applies to the force, you can try ordinary stuff but when it comes to the force, there is no try
Darth Damage Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 He probably just forgot about that ESB scene.
ET Warrior Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 Yes, i would imagine that George Lucas forgot one of the most quoted lines in all of star wars history.... I'm not certain, because it's been awhile since i saw AotC...but i'm almost positive that Yoda says "Gather around the map-reader younglings, and find master obiwans wayward planet we will" I do admit i could be wrong, but i'm almost positive he did not say try.
Taos Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 I agree with ET Warrior....I think Yoda said "we will." It has been a while since I have seen it though, who knows??
leXX Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 I don't remember him saying try either, I'm also sure he says 'we will' or words to that effect!
Pad Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 just saw the video again and sorry to tell u, but yoda doesnt say try. "gather around the mapreader, clear your minds and find obi-wans wayward planet, we WILL."
ckcsaber Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 There is no way GL would contradict Yoda's famous line by putting something like that in
Pad Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 Originally posted by ckcsaber There is no way GL would contradict Yoda's famous line by putting something like that in he didnt do it, i tell u
ET Warrior Posted September 4, 2002 Posted September 4, 2002 Originally posted by Padanime just saw the video again and sorry to tell u, but yoda doesnt say try. "gather around the mapreader, clear your minds and find obi-wans wayward planet, we WILL." I KNEW it!
Dragonlancer Posted September 5, 2002 Author Posted September 5, 2002 yep you guys are right. sorry, my source wasn't very good. See, I like to sketch star wars scenes, so for refference I bought the star wars coloring book. Since little kids like to have those little words in the books, the yoda picture has him saying "find obi-wans wayward planet, we will try." my bad guys.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.