I have a question about Jedi Master Syfodias (or however you spell his name)...

[Darth NeoVenom]

I was curious about knowing who is Jedi Master Syfodias. There is no infomation on him. Another question, who asked for the Clone Army, was it Count Dooku making believe he was Jedi Master Syfodias?

[Darth Groovy]

Probably some meat puppet pawn of Palpatine. I bet Episode III will explain this, they got alot of explaining left to do. For example, whey does Obi, and Yoda dissapear when they die, but not other Jedi like Qui-Gon, and all the Jedi that became cannon fodder in the battle of Geonosis.

 

Hey that's a sexy sig and avatar you got there!

[Darth NeoVenom]

Maybe because they died in peace or were prepared for death. That'z my assumption. Oh and thankz for the compliment Darth Groovy . I made the avatar but someone did the sig for me .

[Darth Groovy]

Originally posted by Darth NeoVenom

Maybe because they died in peace or were prepared for death. That'z my assumption. Oh and thankz for the compliment Darth Groovy . I made the avatar but someone did the sig for me .

 

By chance are his initials DL?

[Darth NeoVenom]

Nah, actually Lost Welshman made it for me. DL made me a sig as well, but not of Darth Maul.

[Breton]

The only thing we know about Sifo Dyas is that he died before TPM. Also, as we also know the Jedi Council did not know about the Sith's return by then, his death was either natural or mysterious.

 

Or, Lama Su could be wrong, and Sifo Dyas is another name for Qui-Gon Jinn.

[Darth NeoVenom]

Correct me if I am wrong...but didn't Obi-Wan Kenobi said that Sifo Dyas died 10 years before Attack of the Clones. That meanz that Sifo Dyas was still alive during The Phantom Menace and he supposely asked for a Clone army right after The Phantom Menace.

[Breton]

Originally posted by Darth NeoVenom

Correct me if I am wrong...but didn't Obi-Wan Kenobi said that Sifo Dyas died 10 years before Attack of the Clones. That meanz that Sifo Dyas was still alive during The Phantom Menace and he supposely asked for a Clone army right after The Phantom Menace.

 

Lama Su asked: "Sifo Dyas is still a leading member of the Jedi Council, is he not?". Yet, he was never at the Jedi Council. Most likely, he died not long before TPM.

 

Just a pleasure to correct you

[Katarn07]

Why would Qui-Gon do it? I never read the theory. Inform us all, JM.

[Breton]

Originally posted by Katarn07

Why would Qui-Gon do it? I never read the theory. Inform us all, JM.

 

At least my belief is that it wasn't Sifo Dyas that ordered the clones - it was Count Dooku acting under that name. But here are some reason on why Sifo Dyas might be Qui-Gon Jinn:

 

-He died almost ten years before AoTC, just as Qui-Gon

-When Lama Su thinks that Sifo is Obi-Wan's master, Obi-Wan does nothing to deny that.

-Count Dooku was Qui-Gon's old master, and therefore it would not be hard for Dooku to assume the identity of Sifo Dyas if he had been so close to him

-When Obi-Wan tells Yoda and Mace Windu about Sifo supposedly having ordered the clones, Yoda and Mace exchange typical "Not again!" looks. Perhaps because this was something Qui-Gon/Sifo would actually do (since Qui-Gon was quite a rebel and did things his own way).

-"Did the council ever authorized the creation of a clone army?". The tone in his voice kind of indicates my previous point, and Obi wasn't very suprised of the answer either.

-As I stated earlier, if Sifo isn't Qui-Gon, he would have to have died just before TPM. But the conditions of the Jedi Council and the Republic is suprisingly calm considering they have just lost one of the leading members of the Council.

 

But on the other hand, there is the "Sifo Dyas is still a leading member of the Jedi Council, is he not?" said by Lama Su. Qui-Gon was never a member of the Jedi Council. On the other hand however, it may have been natural for Lama to think so, as Qui-Gon was one of the leading Jedi Masters, and would defidently have been on the Council if he had been a bit more trustful to it.

[Katarn07]

Interesting. I still hold the Sifo = Dooku theory though. He died, Dooku took the alias in the order. That's what I got outta it. There are 100 page long threads over at SW, but they all come to the same conclusion I think. Wait for EPIII...

[Breton]

Originally posted by Katarn07

Interesting. I still hold the Sifo = Dooku theory though. He died, Dooku took the alias in the order. That's what I got outta it. There are 100 page long threads over at SW, but they all come to the same conclusion I think. Wait for EPIII...

 

Indeed, I too belive Dooku took his identity and ordered the clones. But the question is: Who was Sifo Dyas in the first place? He is barely mentioned at SW.com, wich indicates that they want to keep his identity secret until ep3. Wich means there has got to be something special with it.

[Reborn Outcast]

Originally posted by JM Qui-Gon Jinn

-When Lama Su thinks that Sifo is Obi-Wan's master, Obi-Wan does nothing to deny that.

 

Well, this was because if he had denyed it, then they wouldn't have shown Obi the clone army because they thought it was for Sifo only.

 

Originally posted by JM Qui-Gon Jinn

-"Did the council ever authorized the creation of a clone army?". The tone in his voice kind of indicates my previous point, and Obi wasn't very suprised of the answer either.

 

*cough* bad acting *cough*

 

 

[Darth NeoVenom]

I think too that is was Count Dooku pretending to be Sifo Dyas. Either he took Sifo Dyas identity or he just named himself that.

[Sivy]

there's a web page dedicated to the theory that mace is the traitor and he ordered the clones using Syfodias' name.

i wish i could remember the address.. it had some interesting takes on it

 

now i seriously doubt that it is mace, just as i doubt it was qui-gon.

 

but then until we see ep III and find out for sure, it really could of been anyone

 

jar-jar perhaps, after all he's the mastermind behind it all

 

 

my money's on dooku,

 

he recruited jango & he would of been able to wipe kamino from the archives

[Darth NeoVenom]

That will be extremely funny if it'z Jar Jar Binks...haha

[dark jedi 8]

now i don't think that syfo-dyas is a made up name because obi-wan seemed to know who they were talking about. and when lama su asked if syfo-dyas was still a member of the leading council. obi responded that syfo-dyas had died almost ten years ago, meaning that it would be right after the events of TPM, not before them. i think ep.III will clerify this up for everyone. in the ep.II dvd commentary, GL did say that he would go into more detail into who erased kamino from the arckive memory. it could be the same person who ordered the clone army.

[Darth NeoVenom]

So I was right about Sifo Dyas still being alive in Episode I?

[dark jedi 8]

i'm pretty sure.

and by the way, nice sig!!

[Darth NeoVenom]

Thankz

[BCanr2d2]

Of what we know, it seems as if Sifo Dyas was alive at the time of TPM. With Obi, Yoda and Mace knowing the name when it was mentioned, obviously it was a real life Jedi. Although we don't know how they died, so it could've been something that wasn't totally explained at the time, a "mysterious death" or some weird accident... (A faking their own death thing kind of thing)

 

We are lead to believe that only Dooku is the only Jedi to have left the order, or at least the movie suggests that. So, when they mention the deletion of the information only done by Jedi, so Dooku is the man. AOTC doesn't tell us very much, but has us assuming things, which are no doubt incorrect....

 

My personal theory, R2, he seems to be in everything in the SW universe..............

[Breton]

But Sifo Dyas couldn't have been alive by TPM. He wasn't at the Jedi Council in the movie.

[Darth NeoVenom]

Did they mention all the Jedi Council members in The Phantom Menace? Maybe it was Palpatine. He probably knew who was Syfo Dias and took up his identity. They didn't mention Syfo Dyas in Shadow Hunter and that took place before The Phantom Menace.

[Breton]

The Jedi Council members in TPM are:

 

Yoda

Mace Windu

Ki-Adi-Mundi

Yaddle

Oppo Rancisis

Yarael Poof

Even Piell

Eeth Koth

Plo Koon

Depa Billaba

Adi Gallia

Saesee Tiin

[Darth NeoVenom]

Thankz for the info JM Qui-Gon Jinn. Maybe they will describe more about Sifo Dyas in Episode III. But like I said before, they don't mention anything about him in Shadow Hunter.