Jump to content

Home

Best Lightsaber fight EVER!!!

JediKnight707

By JediKnight707
in Ahto Spaceport Cantina

What is the best Lightsaber fight EVER???  

40 members have voted

  1. 1. What is the best Lightsaber fight EVER???

    • Qui-Gon/Obi-Wan v. Maul
      5
    • Dooku v. Anakin Pt 1
      0
    • Yoda v. Dooku
      1
    • Dooku v. Anakin Pt 2
      0
    • Palpatine v. Yoda
      2
    • Windu v. Palpatine
      2
    • Obi-Wan v. Vader
      22
    • Ben v. Vader
      1
    • Luke v. Vader Pt 1
      5
    • Luke v. Vader Pt 2
      2

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 71
  • Created
  • Last Reply
TheGreenGoblin Newbie

TheGreenGoblin

Posted
Posted
  Kain said:
How can you disagree with the creator of a series when he says what his series was about? Its not exactly a debatable topic.

 

 

Sure I can, I view Star Wars one way, he views it a different way. I still pay to buy all his merchandise, watch his movies, play his games so I'm entitled to that.

 

 

  Insane Sith said:

Luke is focused on, but he's not the main focus like Anakin is(in the grand scheme).

 

 

Is Anakin really the main focus? Of course in the prequels he is, that's without question, but in the Original Trilogy, definitely that focus shifts squarely on his son and is only partially restored to Vader near the end of the RoTJ and even then we're still viewing the story through Luke's eyes.

El Sitherino Newbie

El Sitherino

Posted
Posted
  TheGreenGoblin said:
I'm entitled to that.

You aren't entitled to ****. All you're entitled to is enjoy them or not.

 

 

 

 

  TheGreenGoblin said:
Is Anakin really the main focus? Of course in the prequels he is, that's without question, but in the Original Trilogy, definitely that focus shifts squarely on his son and is only partially restored to Vader near the end of the RoTJ and even then we're still viewing the story through Luke's eyes.

 

Uh... no. The story is told from the droids.

 

And the story is ultimately about Anakin, from conception to redemption, Anakin. With minor focus on the Skywalker family as a whole. Let's compare focus, Anakin: 3.5 movies entire focus on him, Luke: 2, Leia: .5.

 

Anakin wins.

RobQel-Droma Newbie

RobQel-Droma

Posted
Posted

^That is interesting. I always thought that Luke was the actual story, based on how Lucas made the movies, and that I-III are "prequels." I didn't think that there was more emphasis on Anakin.

TheGreenGoblin Newbie

TheGreenGoblin

Posted
Posted

^^^

 

Thank you, couldn't have said it better myself.

 

 

  Insane Sith said:
You aren't entitled to ****. All you're entitled to is enjoy them or not.

 

 

You know, I really don't see a reason to get all hostile here.

 

It's not as if I'm going up to Lucas with a gun and forcing him to say whatever I want. I'm a paying consumer and how I view the product I'm spending my money on shouldn't really bother anyone else.

El Sitherino Newbie

El Sitherino

Posted
Posted

... Who said I was getting hostile?

And your opinion doesn't bother anyone except that you act as though it's fact, when proof has been given otherwise.

 

And order of creation really is of no matter since the saga is now complete and therefore the whole story is before our eyes yada yada, etc.

TheGreenGoblin Newbie

TheGreenGoblin

Posted
Posted
  Insane Sith said:
... Who said I was getting hostile?

And your opinion doesn't bother anyone except that you act as though it's fact, when proof has been given otherwise.

 

And order of creation really is of no matter since the saga is now complete and therefore the whole story is before our eyes yada yada, etc.

 

 

Not once did I pass off what I said as fact:

 

 

In fact the strongest language I used was: "I wouldn't agree on that", "I disagree" , not once did I ever say "NO you are wrong."

 

 

And your "You aren't entitled to ****" came off as hostile.

El Sitherino Newbie

El Sitherino

Posted
Posted
  TheGreenGoblin said:
Is Anakin really the main focus? Of course in the prequels he is, that's without question, but in the Original Trilogy, definitely that focus shifts squarely on his son and is only partially restored to Vader near the end of the RoTJ and even then we're still viewing the story through Luke's eyes.

 

Makes it sound as though you view your opinion as fact. Your use of words conveys a tone of fact, even though you say it's only opinion.

 

And I had no intention of it sounding hostile, merely saying you aren't entitled to anything, regardless of how much crap you buy.

RobQel-Droma Newbie

RobQel-Droma

Posted
Posted

I actually would have agreed with you GreenGoblin, but I never knew that Lucas had said that. I always thought that Anakin was a little bit cooler, but if you asked me, I would have said that Luke was actually the main story. Oh well... I'll say they both have a big emphasis on them.

Jeff Newbie

Jeff

Posted
Posted
  TheGreenGoblin said:
Is Anakin really the main focus? Of course in the prequels he is, that's without question, but in the Original Trilogy, definitely that focus shifts squarely on his son and is only partially restored to Vader near the end of the RoTJ and even then we're still viewing the story through Luke's eyes.
But that's the point of the prequals. Before them the story was able Luke, everyone thought that, but with the prequals complete now, we can see that the story is truly about the rise, fall to darkness, and redemption of Anakin.
joshua05 Newbie

joshua05

Posted
Posted

I voted Obi Vs. Anakin (Vader)

 

It is sooooooo action filled...and...being on the small platform with two lightsabers..that was what really amazed me.

 

ONE of my fav. quotes from that scene is:

 

"Don't try it Anakin, I have the High Ground" ~Obi-Wan

 

^ Because...Obi-Wan DID have the High Ground...he was on the ground at a higher elevation than Anakin (Darth Vader --I'm sorry, but I got this habit of calling him Anakin Skywalker in Eps. !, II, and III ~~~ and calling him Darth Vader in eps. IV, V, and VI)

joshua05 Newbie

joshua05

Posted
Posted

I voted Obi Vs. Anakin (Vader)

 

It is sooooooo action filled...and...being on the small platform with two lightsabers..that was what really amazed me.

 

ONE of my fav. quotes from that scene is:

 

"Don't try it Anakin, I have the High Ground" ~Obi-Wan

 

^ Because...Obi-Wan DID have the High Ground...he was on the ground at a higher elevation than Anakin (Darth Vader --I'm sorry, but I got this habit of calling him Anakin Skywalker in Eps. !, II, and III ~~~ and calling him Darth Vader in eps. IV, V, and VI)

El Sitherino Newbie

El Sitherino

Posted
Posted
  spinkle said:
Gotta love that Obi-Wan kills Maul when he [Maul] has the high ground, then beats Anakin down when the positions are reversed.

Well high ground or not, you can't really do **** when you're blinded by your own ego.

RobQel-Droma Newbie

RobQel-Droma

Posted
Posted

The fight with Darth Maul vs. Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan rules!!!! That is the greatest ever, a Sith with a saberstaff holding off two Jedi. Probably the coolest Sith, because I liked Maul. Greivous was just more cool than anything, that was the only reason I liked him, Dooky-I mean Dooku was just a big fat idiot, but Maul; Even if he was kind of dimwitted and shortsided, he was still cool. Hey, look at his ship, at least he traveled in style :D.

 

And Obi-Wan... My absolute favorite Jedi from the whole series, maybe even better than Anakin. He absolutely pwns everyone! And I like Qui-Gon too, so that combined with the music, the saberstaff against two sabers, and everything else makes it my absolute favorite duel :).

RaV™ Newbie

RaV™

Posted
Posted

Okay thank you, but what was the music they've played in the previews for the BF2 commercials? (seen on lucasarts). I've heard the music during Epi.III, but it sounds a little bit like Duel of the Fates. I also think they played the music during the mustafar duel.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...