Jump to content

Home

Duel of Darkness

Exar Kun II

By Exar Kun II
in Prequel Trilogy

Sauron vs. Sidious  

16 members have voted

  1. 1. Sauron vs. Sidious

    • Sidious, Dark Lord of The Sith
      10
    • Sauron, The Dark Lord of Mordor
      6

Recommended Posts

Exar Kun II Newbie

Exar Kun II

Posted
Posted

I know that we all love Star Wars. I also know that there are many of us that enjoy other fantasy stories, such as a certain saga involving a particular piece of hand jewelry. So, who do you think would win?:D

NemoX Newbie

NemoX

Posted
Posted

No offence to die hard LOTR rings fans, I love LOTR too but Sauron would have no chance whatsoever against Sidious, If the lightning doesn't get him, Sidious will just slice and dice him with the saber without even breaking a sweat.

Ratmjedi Newbie

Ratmjedi

Posted
Posted

He would of done what he did to Gandalf look like a gentle hit on the shoulder. Sidiouse would just throw Sauron high up into the sky or possible into orbit. And the Force Lightining would just turn him into toast.

:lsduel::duel:

NemoX Newbie

NemoX

Posted
Posted
  Quote
Originally posted by Ratmjedi

He would of done what he did to Gandalf look like a gentle hit on the shoulder.

 

That was Saruman(not sure on the spelling), Sauron is the Big guy at the beginning, the one that had his Ring finger cut off by Isiador(Again, not sure on the spelling). Either opponent, Sidious wins no problem, Ring or no Ring, IMHO.

Norin Radd Newbie

Norin Radd

Posted
Posted
  Quote
Originally posted by Lionen

It absolutely depends on if Sauron has the ring or not.

 

Yeah, I agree. If Sauron is able to concentrate his power via the Ring, it would be a tough battle. I believe that ultimately, Sidious would prevail.:)

Pad Newbie

Pad

Posted
Posted

u cant get near sidious for killin him, usin his force and stuff.

as for sauron, he is like seen in the movie, much more mortal.

Jedi_Monk Newbie

Jedi_Monk

Posted
Posted

Sauron and Saruman are both Miar... they're the angels in Tolkien's world. Saruman was sent by the Valar (archangels) for a specific purpose, to keep an eye on Sauron, and therefore he doesn't have as much power... Sauron has his full abilities, he's a demon, a fallen angel. As powerful as Sidious is, he's still mortal, he's still restricted by what he sees as possible and impossible and therfore cannot use the Force to its full extent. Saruman can die, but only because he's assumed a mortal shell... if the shell were destroyed, he would return to the Golden Halls. Sauron can only be destroyed by destroying the Ring because he's poured his whole essence into it. Sidious can die from anything that would kill a normal human.

 

With humans, the Force is something learned, with the Miar... well... they're virtually MADE OF their brand of magic which is almost exactly like the Force. Force against Illuvitar, they're the same thing. Human vs. cellestial being... I'm gonna have to side with Lord of the Rings, here.

 

 

Jedi_Monk.jpg

Sith Inquisitor Newbie

Sith Inquisitor

Posted
Posted

Jedi Monk, I would love to see the library in your home.:D

 

Isildur taking Sauron was nothing more than pure luck, in my opinion. Sauron reached down, no doubt thinking that the knight was defeated, and in a desparate lunge, Isildur took the ring from Sauron's hand.

 

*COUGH*. . .resembles another scenario I can think of.:D

Exar Kun II Newbie

Exar Kun II

Posted
  • Author
Posted
  Quote
Originally posted by Jedi_Monk

Sauron and Saruman are both Miar... they're the angels in Tolkien's world. Saruman was sent by the Valar (archangels) for a specific purpose, to keep an eye on Sauron, and therefore he doesn't have as much power... Sauron has his full abilities, he's a demon, a fallen angel. As powerful as Sidious is, he's still mortal, he's still restricted by what he sees as possible and impossible and therfore cannot use the Force to its full extent. Saruman can die, but only because he's assumed a mortal shell... if the shell were destroyed, he would return to the Golden Halls. Sauron can only be destroyed by destroying the Ring because he's poured his whole essence into it. Sidious can die from anything that would kill a normal human.

 

With humans, the Force is something learned, with the Miar... well... they're virtually MADE OF their brand of magic which is almost exactly like the Force. Force against Illuvitar, they're the same thing. Human vs. cellestial being... I'm gonna have to side with Lord of the Rings, here.

 

 

Jedi_Monk.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Now that is certainly something to contemplate.:)

JediNyt Newbie

JediNyt

Posted
Posted

You shoulda put the "I dont know" option. To be honest I have no idea who would win. Saurons got that cool septer and hes 3 meters tall but Sidious has that lightning. I dont know of any combat powers Sauron has himself besides his physical strangth and his septer. And well Sidious has the Force. Sauron cant do much himself as a spirit besides see everything. So now that I think about it I think Sidious would win. Ya Sidious. Hes got the Force.:D I mean Sauron cant shoot lightning or move things with his mind can he? And how fast do you really think he could move? Ya its Sidous.:lightning

Taos Newbie

Taos

Posted
Posted

I'm gonna go with Sideous......primarily because I don't know who in the hell the other guy is......:confused:

 

I think I'm the only person on these boards who hasn't seen LOTR :rolleyes: oh well...

 

:guiness:

  • 2 weeks later...
Darth Kaan Newbie

Darth Kaan

Posted
Posted
  Quote
Originally posted by leXX

hmmm, this is a tough one! All we have really seen of Sideous so far is his lightning force. hmmm...

 

That and the fact we know Vader was afraid of him.

 

I think Sideous must be one bad dude. Hopefully in EP3 we will get to see him in action other than using force lightning.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...