Woodrodius Posted December 13, 2002 Posted December 13, 2002 Luke is the best Jedi, simply because the story suggests it. That he was the chosen one to bring the Jedi back to balance. Vader beat Obi Wan. Luke beat Vader. One could then assume Luke could beat Obi Wan. Obi Wan Beat Maul. Vader beats Dooku. It can be assumed that Luke could beat these opponents too. The way I look at the speed thing is the way I look at JK2. In the early episodes they used blue stlye. In the later episodes they used Yellow/Red. In JK2, Yellow/Red are the best stances in my opinion. I believe Lucas meant for Luke to be the most powerful Jedi, and movies are canon.
Clemme w/Stick Posted December 13, 2002 Posted December 13, 2002 I would have to say that Anakin is the most powerfull Jedi ever. He even mentioned it a couple of time in AotC. Well, he was right. Anakin/Vader is and will always be the best Jedi, but I like Yoda better. This poll however says the "best jedi", and I believe that will have to be Anakin/Vader! Did I just talk my @$$ off? -Clemme
Danyael Posted December 13, 2002 Posted December 13, 2002 Originally posted by Clemme w/Stick I would have to say that Anakin is the most powerfull Jedi ever. He even mentioned it a couple of time in AotC. Well, he was right. Anakin/Vader is and will always be the best Jedi, but I like Yoda better. This poll however says the "best jedi", and I believe that will have to be Anakin/Vader! Did I just talk my @$$ off? -Clemme no you did not talk your ass off.. you made made a good point. plus, yes to the person above, Luke is the 2nd best Jedi. Yoda may have been very powerful, but well, i have already stated my .02 on that.
RoguePhotonic Posted December 13, 2002 Posted December 13, 2002 mace isn't that good because he gets killed in episode 3 so look at who made it out of that battle and say who is best luke?...hah...I think that story is so cheap...what does it take to train a jedi fully?..15 years or so?...took him 15 days
Danyael Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 Originally posted by RoguePhotonic mace isn't that good because he gets killed in episode 3 so look at who made it out of that battle and say who is best luke?...hah...I think that story is so cheap...what does it take to train a jedi fully?..15 years or so?...took him 15 days soo soo true... i totally agree!!!!! also about the Mace Windu...WTH is everyone saying he is the best JEDI.. we saw him fight what, ONCE?!?!?!? and all he did was knock away a couple of incoming blaster shots and chop Jango's Head off... a total of 15 minutes we saw him.. hmm...
C'jais Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 Originally posted by Danyael soo soo true... i totally agree!!!!! also about the Mace Windu...WTH is everyone saying he is the best JEDI.. we saw him fight what, ONCE?!?!?!? and all he did was knock away a couple of incoming blaster shots and chop Jango's Head off... a total of 15 minutes we saw him.. hmm... Also about Yoda WTH... WTF is everyone saying he's the best JEDI???? We saw him hold off Dooku for what, like 2 minutes??? And Jango, WTF is up with him?? We only saw him kill a lonely, unaware jedi at point blank range... bah! And BOBA!!! Boy oh boy oh boy, don't get me started! Everyone says he's teh best bounty hunter evah, and he what, like doesn't kill anyone??????? w00t? He speaks to vader for what, like 5 whole seconds in that movie??? way to go boba, you're my hero. And palpatine!!! Arrrrgh! He can't even kill some upstart jedi with 2 months of training and a green lightsaber??? WTF is up with dat??? ....
Danyael Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 YOU WROTE: And palpatine!!! Arrrrgh! He can't even kill some upstart jedi with 2 months of training and a green lightsaber??? WTF is up with dat??? True, but remember, The Emporer would have killed Luke, but vader had a change of heart and saved his son... I dont know... i still think Anakin/vader is and was the best jedi.
Breton Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 Qui-Gon Jinn (duh!). He is one of the strongest Jedi in SW, he is simply a perfect light side Jedi, you see that on his fighting style and attitude. Also, he alone made sure that Anakin was to be trained, and had that not happened, then the Empire would never had fallen. He is also one of the coolest SW characters. The only reason he died was because Maul did a cheap trick.
C'jais Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 Originally posted by Danyael True, but remember, The Emporer would have killed Luke, but vader had a change of heart and saved his son... I dont know... i still think Anakin/vader is and was the best jedi. Until now, we haven't seen anything terrifyingly powerful from Anakin - I think I'll make my decision once Ep3 is out.
Danyael Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 Originally posted by Cjais Until now, we haven't seen anything terrifyingly powerful from Anakin - I think I'll make my decision once Ep3 is out. according to the original star wars and the books, anakin killed all the other jedi except yoda and obiwan due to them running into hiding. If you are not the most powerful jedi, would you be able to kill all the rest of them minus the two cowards who ran? (BTW, arent yoda an obi suppose to be strong too? why did the run.) and mace BTW dies, because he is no where in any of the other star wars nor the books. he is not as bad as a MoFo as he thought. lol
C'jais Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 Originally posted by Danyael according to the original star wars and the books, anakin killed all the other jedi except yoda and obiwan due to them running into hiding. If you are not the most powerful jedi, would you be able to kill all the rest of them minus the two cowards who ran? (BTW, arent yoda an obi suppose to be strong too? why did the run.) and mace BTW dies, because he is no where in any of the other star wars nor the books. he is not as bad as a MoFo as he thought. lol But all that is EU, rumours, reputation and a cup of starbuck's. Lucas has not shown us that Anakin "killed all the jedi" yet. Everyone respects Vader (and rightfully so) but the same can be said about Yodie and Mace. Anakin got his arm chopped off in Episode 2. He chops off Luke's hand in Episode 5. He is defeated by Luke in Ep6. Obi, OTOH, gets to kill a very nasty dude with a two bladed saber. He holds off Dooku for at least as long as Anakin. From what we've seen, I can't really make any objective decision yet.
Danyael Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 sure we can...Luke defeated Anakin/Vader after he egged luke on the release his darkside, etc... in Star Wars or The Empire Strikes back, not sure which one, i cannot remember which one said it but yoda or obi said that vader killed all the jedi except for them. (cause of course they went into hiding.) if you look at dooku during the fight with anakin, he is barely holding his own, and when he finally chops off Anakin/Vader's hand, his face is of complete exhaustion. anakin did very very well for only being trained for what 8 years? or whatever it was. dooku was trained for at least 40.. comon.. yoda even said.. "my old padawan" You give anakin 40 years of training and what do you get? vader.. the man, the mystery.. the death of all but one jedi.. his own son. who he had to intentions to kill in the first place. he intentions were to convert luke to the darkside.. and personally. .i wished luke went to the darkside.. would have been cool.. father and son... ruling the galaxy. lol
Matt-Liell Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 Mace Windu = Best! *note* Its Obi-WAN not One!
Kain Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 who voted for ki-adi-mundi? oh wait. no one did! HAHAHA!!!
RoguePhotonic Posted December 14, 2002 Posted December 14, 2002 WTF you guys talking about "oh yoda only held out for like 2 minutes"....uh....he had to save obi and anakin....if dooku thought he could win think he would have done that to get away?
vegietto Posted December 17, 2002 Author Posted December 17, 2002 mace isn't just a good fighting jedi he has great wisdom but he isn't as smart as yoda but he is wise and know his opponent before he fighted him.
lukeskywalker1 Posted December 17, 2002 Posted December 17, 2002 i still think luke was the best. he faught really good.
vegietto Posted December 17, 2002 Author Posted December 17, 2002 yeah he is good but he rushed right into trouble mace take his time and find out what caution he has
vegietto Posted December 17, 2002 Author Posted December 17, 2002 u can't be just a good fighter u have to be wise to be a great jedi
C'jais Posted December 17, 2002 Posted December 17, 2002 Originally posted by lukeskywalker1 i still think luke was the best. he faught really good. And you judge this based on the sloppy saberfighting in ep5+6? yeah he is good but he rushed right into trouble mace take his time and find out what caution he has How do you know this? It's not what he did the few seconds we saw him fighting in ep2.
SettingShadow Posted December 17, 2002 Posted December 17, 2002 Originally posted by Cjais And you judge this based on the sloppy saberfighting in ep5+6? Remember that they didnt put in as much effort for the saber fights as they do in the new movies.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.