Who'll defeat General Grievous?

[Darth Darthy]

I'm going to assume you can read - IT CAME FROM SOMEONE CALLED TERNIAN.

 

I swear to god, if some metions Supershadow again I'm outta here...

[dark jedi 8]

sounds cool, how does grievous escape?

[Darth Darthy]

Punches a hole in the wall/window and walks along the outer hull. How he gets off the burning ship is anyones guess. I assume he hops onto another cruiser seeing as how the docking bay is where the ship is torn in half when it crashes into the other cruiser.

[Darth Rythe]

I think Mace will.

[Sivy]

Originally posted by Jasin Nijol

Where did the human parts come from?

 

i've heard a speculative rumour that greivous is darth maul... or rather what was left of him.

 

of course i don't believe that, but its an interesting thought.

[Poggle]

i've heard a speculative rumour that greivous is darth maul

 

On supershadow by any chance :D

[fourball]

You never know, I mean though ewoks could be pretty vicious sometimes. But chances are Obi shall kill him, but if he killed him with blaster fire, it would be kinda cheap. I dont know about the sequence that you have Darth Darthy, its pretty big to have "leaked" out.

[Ray Stantz]

I think its obvious that Obi-Wan kills Grevious, but there is one problem with that summary of the first few parts of the movie.

 

The problem? Obi-Wan gets knocked out by Grevious I believe. All I know is that I've seen the picture that looks like it has Anakin carrying Obi-Wan through the ship over his shoulder. That and the rumor that Obi-wan gets knocked out.

[Sivy]

this is what I speculate…

I think obi-wan has two encounters with Grevious. First they met while rescuing palpatine at the beginning of the film. Grevious knocks out obi and Anakin saves him, then they have to escape because the ship is crashing.

later I think obi-wan is given the task by the jedi council of taking a team of jedi and hunting Grevious down. This time obi-wan comes out better and kills Grevious, not before Grevious kills most, if not all, of the team of jedi (which includes aayla secura and Ki-Adi-Mundi, who have already meet Grevious)

[Mike Windu]

I think it'll definitely be obi who takes care of Grievous.

[fuzzyfreaker]

obi sounds like the best chance, i mean even though he's gonna get a lot of screentime, it doesn't sound like he'll kill anybody important. So i'm going with Obi-Wan

[Super Clone]

Originally posted by dark jedi 8

i also hear that sidious kicks yoda's ass in a duel.

yoda get defeated in a duel?!? :yoda3WOW!

[Nairb Notneb]

I think Obi killing GG with a blaster would be too random and clumsy. There's nothing elegant about it, however it would be ironic, I like it. One might call it luck even, right Han?

[Nairb Notneb]

Your overconfidence is your weakness.

[Alegis]

You may have heard that obi kills him, but thats a lie. As the BEST friend of george lucas, I, superalegis, have the honour of telling all of you that a small party of ewoks will bring this evil icon down. A lot of bothans will randomly die.

[Watutu]

obi wan does kill him, he shoots him wiv a blaster, right in the gut

 

 

anyway the bothans dont randomly die, the ewoks do

[Watutu]

ok maybe i should hav done a spoiler on that

[Sivy]

Originally posted by Watutu

ok maybe i should hav done a spoiler on that

 

no need, this is the 'spoilers allowed' forum so you don't have to warn people. however if you post in the 'spoiler-free' forum then tags must be used.

 

you seem you have a nasty habbit of double-posting. in future please use the 'edit' button if you wish to add something to your first post.

[Vagabond]

Okay, I may have some of my facts wrong because I'm doing this from memory, but I think by the process of elimination we have:

 

1. Mace probably gets killed by Greivous, because I believe it's been stated that he doesn't get killed by the Emperor or Anakin, and since we also know that Mace doesn't go out like a "punk", then the only respectable foe left would be Grievous. That being the case, Mace could not kill Grievous.

 

2. The Emperor probably would not kill his military commander, as The Emperor typically leaves the dirty work to others. Specifically, he tends to like to pit his underlings against each other. Although imagine the load Grievous would drop in his shorts if at the end, the Emperor turned on him But let's just assume that cool stuff doesn't happen in the Prequel Trilogy.

 

3. Obi-wan is the one who defeats Anakin, probably just barely, by somehow outwitting him - pretty much common knowledge. As such, since this movie isn't titled the "Obi-wan story", it's probably safe to assume that Obi-wan doesn't defeat two of the main characters in the same movie, thusly eliminating him from the contender list.

 

4. Yoda could potentially dispatch with Grievous with some effort. However, what I would rather see is the "Mother of all Showdowns" ... Yoda -vs- the Emperor, which according to the non-cool assumption, won't happen. So to the point, I think Yoda will be too busy on Kashyyyk and shuttling babies around to have an opportunity to vanquish this villain.

 

5. Which leaves us with the only primary suspect unaccounted for - Anakin. One might say, "But Greivous and Anakin will be on the same side". True, from a certain point of view. But as we all know, Grievous is not in the Original Trilogy. Further, after Anakin slays Dooku, taking his place as the Emperor's new apprentice, and due to Anakin's keen military leadership, there will be no further need for the services of Grievous. And with the commission of that act, Anakins ... excuse me, Darth Vader will further cement his destiny to the Emperor. But as we all know, even the strongest of stone crumbles with time...

[Nairb Notneb]

Ok Vagabond, I like it when somebody around here actually uses their head for something other than a hat rack. Maybe I'll try it too some day It just might work. I'll go with your Anakin idea, but would Anakin beat a foe that Mace couldn't beat? Meaning is Anakin a better warrior that Mace? Or does that even matter? Mace can be better than Ani but not be able to beat Grievous but Anakin can be able to beat Grievous. Ouch, that hurt my head. Here's another thought. Maybe Mace dies in a self-sacrifice effort killing himself and Grievous at the same time going out with a bang.

[Vagabond]

Thank, Nairb Notneb. I'll try to answer some of your questions - could Anakin beat someone that Mace couldn't beat? Hmmm, possibly, if power in the Force were more important than skill with a lightsaber. My impression of the Mace / Yoda duo, is that Yoda is the force-dude, and Mace is the brawn-dude. And plus, we never know - perhaps the Emperor teaches Anakin some dark-side tricks that could help him more easily dispatch Grievous - dark side tricks that Mace wouldn't delve into as he's unwilling to cross into the darkness.

 

Your comment about Mace killing himself is interesting, although I believe it's been said that Mace dies with a group of others - (others weren't specified, but assumed to be Jedi - could be the youngling though, who knows?) - and that Mace survived the longest before going out "in a blaze of glory". It is possible that he takes Grievous with him - not a bad theory. I do think Mace will die doing something heroic - at least I hope - it's good that he's not dying like a punk, but at the same time, I want his death to have meaning too, not just that he sucked more than the guy he was fighting. A worthy, meaningful sacrifice - that's what's called for with Mace's death.

 

Sorry about the ramble

[Nairb Notneb]

I agree. I think Mace biting the bullet saving a lot of innocents, killing Grievous in a self-sacrificing move would be a proper way for a Jedi to die. I think you are right about Yoda, being the "brains or Force" and Windu being the brawn behind the duo, though Yoda seems to be able to hold his own in a fight.

 

Anakin possibly could defeat Grievous in a way Mace could not if he has learned the Sith lightning attack by this time. With that electrical attack, it should short out the electrical systems of his cyborb/droid body parts quite easily. Mace could not do that being a Jedi but little old Sith Ani/Darth Vader could if he new that attack.

[DarthTDe]

Originally posted by Squee-sithguy

Obi wan, it is pretty much confirmed. There is also a rumor that Obi kills greivous with a blaster

 

 

 

Yep,you is right Squee.It's obi-wan:he cuts him straight down and fires Grievous's(sp?) blaster at his internal organs.(eeeewwwww!)

[Nairb Notneb]

I've been hearing that he does it on Naboo during a Battle but i don't know for certain.

[Revan Solo]

I think it will be Obi Wan because he is the most famous Jedi but I do not know much about Grievous!