Who Is Your Favorite Sith Lords (ranking system)?

[SilentScope001]

Alright, I want to know who is this community's favorite sith lord.

 

You have four choices: Sion, Nihilus, Kreia, and Malak. You can rank them from 1 to 4. 1st place gets 3 votes, 2nd place gets 2 votes, and 3rd place gets 1 vote.

 

Once we get enough entries, I'll calcuate how many votes each person has, and use that to know who is indeed the most popular Sith Lord. This would avoid the problems with a plurarity, and allow for the will of the people to be expressed. Let's start.

 

SilentScope001's vote:

1. Kreia

2. Nihilus

3. Sion

4. Malak

 

Topsite's Vote:

1. Sion

2. Traya

3. Malak

4. Nihilus

[Arátoeldar]

1. Kreia

2a. Sion

2b. Malak

4. Nihilus

[Jediphile]

1st Nihilus

2nd Traya

3rd Sion

38473893th Malak [insert missing :shifty: smiley here]

[axel]

1st nihilus

2nd sion

3rd traya

4rth Malak

[Ctrl Alt Del]

1)Nihilus

2)Traya

3)Malak

4)Sion

[Venom750]

1) Malak

2)Sion

3)Traya

4)Nihilus

[EnIgmA_XX]

1.Kreia

2.Sion

3.Malak

4.Nihilus

[The Architect]

1st Nihilus

2nd Traya

3rd Sion

38473893th Malak [insert missing :shifty: smiley here]

 

ROFL! This forum needs a shifty smilie. Like this: http://forums.obsidianent.com/index.php?s=&showtopic=45370&view=findpost&p=758390

 

The one in the second paragraph.

 

1. Darth Traya

2. Darth Nihilus

3. Darth Sion

4 x 100 x 500 x … (Whoops. I’ve run out of space). Darth Cheese (Malak)

[SilentScope001]

Current Stats:

 

Kreia: 3+2+3+2+1+2+1+3+3=20

 

Sion: 1+3+2+1+2+2+2+1=12

 

Nihilus: 2+3+3+3=11

 

Malak: 1+1+1+3+1=7

[Diego Varen]

If it is alright with you SilentScope001, I just thought to count the votes now, until you do. Also, why didn't we have the other Sith Lords, like Bandon? Anyway, since SilentScope001 has posted my vote, I'll post the first scores here. I'm assuming that if someone is fourth, they recieve no points. If I have the results wrong, please inform me, since I'm not too good at Maths.

 

SilentScope001's vote:

1. Kreia 3

2. Nihilus 2

3. Sion 1

4. Malak 0

 

(My) Topsite's vote:

1. Sion 3

2. Traya 2

3. Malak 1

4. Nihilus 0

 

Arátoeldar's vote:

1. Kreia 3

2a. Sion 2

2b. Malak 2

4. Nihilus 1

 

Jediphile's vote:

1st Nihilus 3

2nd Traya 2

3rd Sion 1

38473893th Malak [insert missing :shifty: smiley here] 0

 

axel's vote:

1st nihilus 3

2nd sion 2

3rd traya 1

4rth Malak 0

 

Ctrl_Alt_Del's vote:

1)Nihilus 3

2)Traya 2

3)Malak 1

4)Sion 0

 

Venom750's vote:

1) Malak 3

2)Sion 2

3)Traya 1

4)Nihilus 0

 

EnIgmA_XX's vote:

1.Kreia 3

2.Sion 2

3.Malak 1

4.Nihilus 0

 

The Architect's vote:

1. Darth Traya 3

2. Darth Nihilus 2

3. Darth Sion 1

4 x 100 x 500 x … (Whoops. I’ve run out of space). Darth Cheese (Malak) 0

 

Results (Until SilentScope001 does the final tally/results)

 

1st. Kreia/Traya 30

Joint 2nd. Sion And Nihilus 14

3rd. Malak 8

 

Edit: I've spent quite a long time on this and SilentScope001 must have posted while I was doing this. If you want this deleted SilentScope001, feel free to tell me and I will delete this.

[Vaelastraz]

1.) Malak

2.) Traya

3.) Sion

1337.) Nihilus

[SilentScope001]

Edit: I've spent quite a long time on this and SilentScope001 must have posted while I was doing this. If you want this deleted SilentScope001, feel free to tell me and I will delete this.

 

...Why not? Anything that allows me to avoid work is good. Thanks Topsite.

[Titanius Anglesmith]

1.) Traya

2.) Nihilus

3.) Sion

Whatever 10 to the 800th power is.) Malak

[Trex]

1) Kreia

2)Sion

3)Nihilus

4)Malak

[Emperor Devon]

(1. Kreia

 

(2. A tie between Sion, Nihilus and Malak

[playloud]

1) Malak/Traya. (I like how evil and ruthless Malak was, but I like how manipulative Traya was.

 

3) Sion: Could have been good if he was given more depth.

 

4) Nihilus: Absolutely hated the idea of this guy. This is what I call the Kevin J. Anderson effect. The need to top previous efforts by such an extreme that it is stupid. This character was way too powerful. Eating planets and such. Bah! By making him so powerful, it cheapens the whole idea. What can they do in K3 that exceeds this ability?

 

It is like when Kevin J. Anderson introduced the Sun Crusher. Destroying a planet wasn't enough. We need to destroy solar systems now! Oh, and the armor on this thing is indestructible (read the Jedi Academy series of books). Not to be outdone in his series of books, Mr. Anderson has a group of Jedi n00bs (just started training with Luke) knock a fleet of star destroyers out of the system by using the Force. This is something that we have not even remotely seen in the movies.

 

This is why I like the Timothy Zahn novels best. The Thrawn trilogy was absolute gold, in that it stayed believable in relation to the movies.

 

In relation to this post, that is why I hate Nihilus. He is far too powerful to be consistent with that we have seen in the Star Wars universe.

[SilentScope001]

playloud, if you hated Nihilus, why put him at 3, thereby giving Nihilus 1 tiny vote? Why not place Kreia at 3 and Nihilus at 4?

 

Hm...EDs vote does sound a bit unconventional considering the ranking system. Is it good to assume he only voted for one candinate and that he elected not to use the 2nd and 3rd ranking, so that the other sides gets an equal amount of votes, being none? Or is another way of calcuating EDs vote is neccessary?

[Diego Varen]

Hm...EDs vote does sound a bit unconventional considering the ranking system. Is it good to assume he only voted for one candinate and that he elected not to use the 2nd and 3rd ranking, so that the other sides gets an equal amount of votes, being none? Or is another way of calcuating EDs vote is neccessary?

 

I suppose Sion, Nihilus and Malak recieve two points each, since they are joint second, or at least that was how I counted the previous joint second places, etc. Also, SilentScope001, if you want me to count the results over time, when do you think I should do it, since we shouldn't count the results too often.

[playloud]

playloud, if you hated Nihilus, why put him at 3, thereby giving Nihilus 1 tiny vote? Why not place Kreia at 3 and Nihilus at 4?

I changed Nihilus to 4.

[SilentScope001]

I suppose Sion, Nihilus and Malak recieve two points each, since they are joint second, or at least that was how I counted the previous joint second places, etc.

 

Ah, okay. In any case, it would count as basically the same in the long run, so I'll agree with you.

 

Also, SilentScope001, if you want me to count the results over time, when do you think I should do it, since we shouldn't count the results too often.

 

Once every week should do.

[Diego Varen]

Once every week should do.

 

Sounds good. It is Tuesday for me now, so I'll do it on Sundays. If I have time, I will edit reasons into my Ranking, like playloud did, since before I couldn't be bothered. This Thread is really interesting and things are starting to heat up.

[kotor_freak]

Aha! My top 4 are the best!

 

1) Me.

2) Coco the monkey.

3) Pop (Rice krispies)

4) Mickey Mouse.

 

Nah seriously now...

 

1) Kreia/Traya

2) Sion

3) Nihilius

4) Malak

[playloud]

So many people hate Malak. At least he was within the realm of what we have seen in Star Wars (by that, I mean on screen). He ordered the destruction of a planet, but he needed a fleet of ships to do it. He ruled through fear. He was not a god-like being who killed whole planets with a thought. Aside from his maniacal laugh, he was very Vader-like, and therefore worthy of placement above that joke called Nihilus.

[Son of Skywalker15]

1.) Kreia/Traya

2.) Malak

3.) Sion

4.) Nihilus

 

Kreia definitely was the most capable of being a great Sith Lord; training Revan, Sion, Nihilus. The only thing she feared, ironically, was the force. Rather, she feared it because she hated it.

[Rockstar]

My vote:

 

1)Nihilus

2)Traya

3)Malek

4)Sion

 

 

I find it silly how some of the Sion fans sledge Nihilus just because he was more powerful.

 

Ask any person in the street. Show them pictures of all 3 sithlords and i guarantee you that they would rate Nihilus at number one (hands down) and probably Darth Sion last (he really doesn't look like the second last boss...)

 

Common, when you first saw Nihilus in his cutscene, did you not believe he would be the final, or second final boss? lol

 

He was made bland by no screen time, and TG's refusal to put in an essentual cut scene makes this worse with the RP... did anybody else not really understand what happened in the dual between exile and nihilus till after the dual? They really should have included that cut scene... even if the sion fans cried about it , obsidion planned for it to be in the game and Nihilus WAS more powerful than Sion. any way...