Jump to content

Home

X-Men 3 Good/Bad Debate


Recommended Posts

Posted

From what I've seen of the previews this kicks butt, but also like the other movies they got the story all screwed up like: no Remy (Gambit) before The Phoenix (Jean Grey), Roque's crush on Magneto, no Apocalypse before the "Final Confrontation" and no Sentinels. Just to name a few mistakes. Thoughts anyone?

  • Replies 119
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

The fact that Angel was an original founding member rather than just now being introduced was the first thing I rolled my eyes at ;)

 

But yeah, I'm still going to see this movie.. storyline or not, the movie looks bad-ass :D

Posted
From what I've seen of the previews this kicks butt, but also like the other movies they got the story all screwed up like: no Remy (Gambit) before The Phoenix (Jean Grey), Roque's crush on Magneto, no Apocalypse before the "Final Confrontation" and no Sentinels. Just to name a few mistakes. Thoughts anyone?

I don't believe those are mistakes. From what I understand from the commentary, they intentionally made changes to the story. As a former long-time X-Men comicbook collector, I can say that I love the movies as much as the comicbooks. When it comes to the movies, they take their artistic liscence to make something marketable. Yeah. I was hoping to see Gambit more than Collassus, but what can you do.

 

I wouldn't go by the TV Series, for they broke so many comicbook cannon rules.

 

Remember, Gambit and Rouge actually have a relationship. At this point in the comicbooks, Rouge doesn't have a relationship with Magneto.

 

Truthfully, I like the daughter-father relationship between Rouge and Logan.

 

I think the movie is going to do better than Superman-V.

Posted

Like I Said " The movie looks like it kicks butt". Ice-Man was one of the founding members also with FireStar, yet he just got there when Rogue did.

 

I just think they are overstepping the line here. I used to collect comics also, well that is untill one of my ex-friends sister's destroyed my Superman Collection. Yes I know this it's re-mentioned in the game "X-Men Legends" all I'm saying for a little while she had a crush on magneto not relationship. Yes the Dad/Daughter relationship is good, espesially since in the first movie he seems as if he hates her when he first met her. Anyhow Logan and Remy are my favorite Characters.

 

PS: We can say Ass? or is it one of those "how you say it" things

Posted

I love X-men so much, and im happy about the Phoenix being it only thing is i don't want Cyke to die as somone dies in this film as you can see in the trilor.

 

 

But thi is going to be a great film .

Posted

I never really had the comic books as a kid, but I did watch the TV show. It wasn't until later that I learned how bad that show screwed things up...

 

I can't wait to see this movie. It looks amazing.

Posted

I'm really psyched for this film. About time they brought in Beast, something more than a small cameo on a t.v. screen, & Kelsey Grammer for the role....perfect.

Posted

Well, I never have looked at the comics, but the films thus-far have been really good... so you can say I am looking forward to this one.

 

I love Ian McKellan as Magneto... the movies also have Famke in them, and that is never a bad thing. :D

Posted

The first two parts were great, so the third part just can't not be good. The only thing I don't like is that Nightcrawler won't be in the third part.

Posted

About the funeral thing: I just kinda assumed that was Jean's funeral (seeing as how she "died" at the end of X2). I thought maybe it would be one of the beginning scenes or something.

 

BUT I did hear that some ppl were supposed to die in the movie....

Posted

Jean comes back as "The Phoenix", guess you didn't see that preview. I'm still aggravated that there isn't "The Apocalypse" or Gambit before "The Last Stand" against Magneto.

Posted

Yes, she's Phoenix none the less.

If you watch some of the Extras on X2 disc 2 he has an interview and he says specifically "Never again" when he is asked about doing Nightcrawler in the 3rd installment.

Posted

He wasn't very happy with the 10hrs of Makeup a day along with Touchups and Re-touchups... or so I recall.

 

It seems none of the staff took him very seriously... as he started to say this the makeup staff started laughing and continued laughing until after was finished speaking.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...