What's the big deal about Revan?

[Astor]

Recently, I seem to have noticed that Revan seems to attract a fair amount of fanboyism, almost on a scale similar to the Fetts (but that's another matter).

 

I've noticed in various threads, such as 'Revan vs. XXXX character, who would win?', that Revan invariably wins, because he is 'teh uber'. And some of the comments are quite strange - 'Revan wins because he is the best at everything', often with no verifiable sources or reasoning - he's just simply 'the best'.

 

So, my question is this - What is it about Revan that causes people to obsess?

 

I'm not asking this to cause an argument, i'm genuinely interested in why people idolise him in such a way.

 

Discuss

[JoeDoe 2.0]

Well, his sense of style and the fact that he survived Kreia could be why

 

I think is because all the mystery that surrounds Revan makes people like him (not much was said on the games about his past) plus he wields great power and he's a gifted Jedi Knight/Sith Lord and sort of a rebel

[Inyri]

You should notice that it's not just Revan, but most main-character Sith Lords seem to attract such attention. Vader has his share of fanboys (even more, now since there's the added benefit of Vader fanboys plus Anakin fanboys, and since they're the same person they kind of meld into one). Sidious and Maul also have quite a following.

 

The 'Revan fanboyism' only seems to be amplified here because this is a KotOR forum.

 

The only reason Malak doesn't have a fanboy following is because Revan took the cake on that one. The appeal with Revan is probably also amplified because he was not only one of the most powerful Sith Lords (and one of the first), but he was also a very powerful light-side Jedi, so you get fans from both ends of the spectrum.

[patient_zero]

The way I see it, it's because you are Revan, so when judging them against other characters people up his/her abilities because it's a way of thinking that it's them that can beat up Darth Vader/(Insert Other Powerful Character Here) with their bare fists. The Exile gets the same treatment but to a lesser extent, though I think this might be because more people seem to have played/enjoyed K1, and the fact that The Exile was never Dark Lord/Lady Of The Sith.

 

Plus, most of K1 has people bigging up Revan's skills in tactics and the Force and such in order to make "the reveal" all the more powerful. Then the second has a combination of that and chucks in the idea of Revan having really been "good" all along, meaning even people who don't have evilgasms at the idea of being a Sith Lord can idolise Revan's power.

[TKA-001]

I view Revan/Exile fanboyism as fictional self-glorification, fantasy fulfillment, and close-mindedness on the part of legions of empty-headed fangirls (and a significantly smaller number of equally empty-headed fanboys). If you've ever been to the KFM forums, you'll know what I'm talking about.

[Astor]

I view Revan/Exile fanboyism as fictional self-glorification, fantasy fulfillment, and close-mindedness on the part of legions of empty-headed fangirls (and a few fanboys). If you've ever been to the KFM forums, you'll know what I'm talking about.

 

That really does make sense, and I think I can sort of agree. So, it goes like this - Revan saves the galaxy, becoming the greatest (that's debatable) Jedi, wielding awesome powers, so, by extension, the player becomes 'awesome'.

 

Vader has his share of fanboys (even more, now since there's the added benefit of Vader fanboys plus Anakin fanboys, and since they're the same person they kind of meld into one). Sidious and Maul also have quite a following.[/Quote]

 

True, but I count myself as a Vader/Sidious Fanboy

[Inyri]

I used to be a bit of a Vader fangirl until the prequels came out. That fairly well ruined it for me. x.X

[Marius Fett]

I used to be a bit of a Vader fangirl until the prequels came out. That fairly well ruined it for me.

 

To be honest, I think the prequels killed Star Wars. AotC was pretty good, RotS was ok, but TPM was just terrible.

 

Long live the originals though!

[Inyri]

See, I'd say RotS sucked, AotC was barely okay, and TPM was acceptable (more in hindsight than at the time). TPM actually had a lot of great actors, Liam Neeson being most prominent in that category. Plus the duel with Darth Maul is arguable the best lightsaber duel in all 6 movies (it's not ridiculously unrealistic like the ones in AotC and RotS).

 

I think things like those 'ridiculous' saber battles is what feeds fanboyism. For those of us that prefer something more realistic, though, it destroys it quite well. It's an interesting point in the 'fanboy' debate, I think, and deserves merit.

 

Just imagine if there had been some Revan/Malak/Exile lightsaber duel cutscenes. Imagine how much MORE people would obsess over them.

[jonathan7]

See, I'd say RotS sucked, AotC was barely okay, and TPM was acceptable (more in hindsight than at the time). TPM actually had a lot of great actors, Liam Neeson being most prominent in that category. Plus the duel with Darth Maul is arguable the best lightsaber duel in all 6 movies (it's not ridiculously unrealistic like the ones in AotC and RotS).

 

I think things like those 'ridiculous' saber battles is what feeds fanboyism. For those of us that prefer something more realistic, though, it destroys it quite well. It's an interesting point in the 'fanboy' debate, I think, and deserves merit.

 

Just imagine if there had been some Revan/Malak/Exile lightsaber duel cutscenes. Imagine how much MORE people would obsess over them.

 

I don't quite understand the obsession with Revan; in that she (in my universe Revan is a woman, but thats another issue) is undoubtley one of the most powerful forces users of the period, but that doesnt make you invincible.

 

I liked RotS, I thought AotC and TPM were ok, but no this George; I would have a better script and better films; which says alot as I have about as much filming ability as a squirrel.

[SilentScope001]

I view Revan/Exile fanboyism as fictional self-glorification, fantasy fulfillment, and close-mindedness on the part of legions of empty-headed fangirls (and a significantly smaller number of equally empty-headed fanboys). If you've ever been to the KFM forums, you'll know what I'm talking about.

 

Amen. Any type of fanboyism has some self-glorification. In fact, since you play as Revan/Exile, you can see them both as just being 'Mary Sues', that YOU are the one who is awesome. Mary Sues are great...for the person who is the Mary Sue, but it's not great for, say, everyone else.

 

People however play games for fun, which often times mean fufilling the ego. I mean, would you really want to play as Stormtrooper #59,681,954,013, who gets blown up by Rebel troopers about 5 seconds into combat? I know I would. I know everyone else wouldn't.

[Ravnas]

Amen. Any type of fanboyism has some self-glorification. In fact, since you play as Revan/Exile, you can see them both as just being 'Mary Sues', that YOU are the one who is awesome. Mary Sues are great...for the person who is the Mary Sue, but it's not great for, say, everyone else.

 

People however play games for fun, which often times mean fufilling the ego. I mean, would you really want to play as Stormtrooper #59,681,954,013, who gets blown up by Rebel troopers about 5 seconds into combat? I know I would. I know everyone else wouldn't.

 

Unless you are incredibly modest and pessimistic But Revan is over hyped. I personally prefer the Exile due to that it is never mentioned if he/she is a high ranking General in the war.

[Corinthian]

Revan Fanboyism is no surprise. TSL just amplified it by making Kreia play up Revan - He never really fell, he was the Heart of the Force...I was expecting her to canonize him as Saint Darth Revan in a minute.

[jonathan7]

Revan Fanboyism is no surprise. TSL just amplified it by making Kreia play up Revan - He never really fell, he was the Heart of the Force...I was expecting her to canonize him as Saint Darth Revan in a minute.

 

They have cannonized far worse; im trying to decide if I can be bothered to go into Photoshop to make this image happen.

[JCarter426]

So, my question is this - What is it about Revan that causes people to obsess?

 

I have no clue. I honestly don't. I think this is one of those cases where you don't know what it means to be one unless you are one, and if you are one, you'll never admit it (a strange parallel to Revan's Sithiness).

 

Other people's overinflated opinion of Revan have virtually spoiled the character for me (that, and he's an arrogant fool with a god complex ). Fortunately, few people like the Exile, so I've still got her by my side (though I'll admit that I have an overinflated opinion of her, to counter the general underestimation of the Exile ).

[Miles Edgeworth]

Long live the originals though!

 

Pfft! Originals Fanboy...

 

Honestly, I dont know what causes Revan fanboys, I always thought that most PCs are shallow characters. I remember yesterday's PotD on KotORFiles, I remember how many times I resisted posting, because of stuff like this:

 

In this 5 five year Revan could learn everything that he lost, and became stronger than before. Remember the Words of Malak: "Well done, Revan. I was certain the defenses of the Star Forge would destroy you, but I see there is more of your old self in you than I expected. You are stronger than I thought; stronger than you ever were during your reign as the Dark Lord. I did not think that was possible." If Revan was stronger on the Star Forge than before, then five year later HE IS INVINCIBLE.

[JK24]

IMHO, there's a combination of reasons for why people obsess about Revan. Like others have said, one of the reasons is that you get to play as him in K1 and that gives the impression that they are actually Revan and that way they increase his abilities considerably and over the edge. Another valid reason that has been mentioned before, is that Revan was one of the greatest Sith Lords/Jedi Knights of his era and so he gets fanboys from both sides of the barricade. Yet another reason for the obsession with Revan is that he's the Anakin Skywalker of his era...incredible force potential and great lightsaber skills. Eventually people get bored with Anakin and so move on to another character with similar characteristics to the Chosen One, in this case Revan.

 

I definetely think that the exaggerated fanboyism is hurting Revan as a character though and some arguments I have seen for Revan winning a battle are just plain ridiculous. I won't lie, I'm probably infected with Revan fanboyism as well, but I still don't think he's all-powerful, invincible or 'teh uber'. I just like to think of him as one of the greatest Jedi/Sith Lords of his era, because that's what he actually is.

[Ctrl Alt Del]

I view Revan/Exile fanboyism as fictional self-glorification, fantasy fulfillment, and close-mindedness on the part of legions of empty-headed fangirls (and a significantly smaller number of equally empty-headed fanboys). If you've ever been to the KFM forums, you'll know what I'm talking about.

Revan Fanboyism is no surprise. TSL just amplified it by making Kreia play up Revan - He never really fell, he was the Heart of the Force...I was expecting her to canonize him as Saint Darth Revan in a minute.

Quoted for truth.

 

Alas, Revan fanboyism is fine. The excess is nocive to the whole sect of praisers, though. People get weary after so much love diplay.

[Serpentine Cougar]

I like Revan, but he's not the best character I've ever seen, or my favorite. The reason I like Revan isn't for any qualities or merits of his own. (So you were a really skilled general and strategist and really powerful in the ways of the force? Aren't we all...) I like him mainly just for the plot twist that centers around him in the Kotor story.

[JCarter426]

The reason I like Revan isn't for any qualities or merits of his own. (So you were a really skilled general and strategist and really powerful in the ways of the force? Aren't we all...) I like him mainly just for the plot twist that centers around him in the Kotor story.

 

My reason exactly.

[adamqd]

As said before it's because you are Revan, and also because it was such a cool new look at Star Wars, Game, era and story wise. theres only so many times you can relive someone else's journey, with kotOR you got the custom game play and re-play value. People are bound to get attached to a character if it's actually "you".

[JCarter426]

Then why isn't it the same with the Exile? I'm inclined to say that it's because the Exile is female, but this was the case long before that was entered into canon. Could be that more people have played K1 than 2, I guess (but that's another matter ).

[JK24]

Then why isn't it the same with the Exile? I'm inclined to say that it's because the Exile is female, but this was the case long before that was entered into canon. Could be that more people have played K1 than 2, I guess (but that's another matter ).

 

Maybe it's also because of K2's darker atmosphere. It might be that people prefer games with lighter atmoshperes and an actual ending, but yeah there's also the possibility that more have played K1 than K2.

[jonathan7]

Personally I think Revan was a very Gifted force user, probably in Battle Meditation, a supreme leader while i think the Exile was a lesser leader, I always think that the Exile is the more gifted one on one fighter; and is quite probably under rated by many.

 

In my universe Revan is a woman, while the Exile is a man.

[JCarter426]

Personally I think Revan was a very Gifted force user, probably in Battle Meditation

 

I highly doubt that. For instance, the Jedi strike team probably wouldn't have been able to board his ship if that were the case, since they were only able to do so through Bastila's Battle Meditation.

 

while i think the Exile was a lesser leader

 

Actually, it's the Exile who Kreia notes is "something more" than a leader.